The Quibéron mutinies were a series of mutinies that occurred in the Brest squadron of the French Navy in September 1793, at the height of the Reign of Terror. They offered reasons and pretexts for the Jacobins to purge the Navy of most of its officers who belonged to the French aristocracy. The event was interpreted as both a culmination of the disorganisation of the French Navy from 1790, and a cause of its disorganisation in the following years.
After several months of cruise, a large squadron stationed off Quiberon mutinied and demanded to sail back to harbour. The mutineers took pretext of the surrender of Toulon to a combined Anglo-Spanish force, arguing that their presence in Brest was required to prevent Royalist conspirators from surrendering Brest as well; in the face of overt rebellion, and incapable of maintaining discipline and order, Vice-admiral Morard de Galles took upon himself to order the return to Brest.
In consequence, représentant en mission Jean Bon Saint-André, the naval expert of the National Convention, was called to Brest to reestablish order and reorganise the Navy. The following repression claimed relatively few lives in the Navy, but argued of a putative Royalist plot by Navy officers loyal to the Ancien Régime to explain the incident. In consequence, a number of officers were relieved of duty and arrested, including two admirals.
Background The collapse of the French absolute monarchy with the French Revolution had an important impact on the French Navy: the Navy was strongly linked to the monarchy by its officer corps, largely recruited from the nobility, and trained in highly technical disciplines; it was also enormously dependent on funds and supplies to maintain ships and crews. The collapse of Royal power triggered a shift of authority towards local governments, the revolutionary municipalities. These municipalities were both the rivals of the former centres of authority under the Ancien Régime, and potential rivals to the central power in Paris.Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p.31
The fleet was weakened by supply difficulties, such as a chronic lack of clothes which made the crews suffer greatly at sea. At Quibéron, the crews were isolated from the shore, and started to run low on food. After four months at sea, they were fed mostly with salted food.Kerguelen, p. 353
Chronic indiscipline reigned amongst the crews: sailors would quit their ships after reviews, or refuse to depart, arguing that the ships were being sailed in order to be surrendered to the British; the municipalities had to intervene and help the Navy convince these sailors to obey. The climate deteriorated to the point that in the night of 6 August, part of Northumberland's standing rigging was sabotaged. In March, after Jean Bart and Trajan were sent to Vannes, a significant proportion of their crews deserted.Nofficial, p. 10 In May, in the face of rapid devaluation of the currency, crewmen from the frigates Engageante and Proserpine refused to embark unless they were paid in advance; consequently, on 17 May, 150 men from Proserpine, out of a 260-man complement, failed to report for duty.Nofficial, (p. 10) Some of the crewmen considered their duty to scrutinise their own officers, and regarded themselves, as representative of the French people, to be legitimate sources of authority.
Emigration of Navy officers by March 1792 Rank Present % Absent % Total Vice-admiral 2 - 7 - 9 Rear-admiral 2 - 15 - 18 Captain 42 25% 128 75% 170 Lieutenant 356 67% 174 33% 530Source: Nofficial, p. 10 Sailors had lost their trust in their officers, who tended to be suspicious of each other as well. Navy officers from the French Royal Navy of the Ancien Régime, the officiers rouges, openly despised the new social order brought about by the French First Republic, and were particularly frustrated by the lack of discipline generated by the philosophy of égalité, as highly detrimental to the organisation of the Navy. Nevertheless, some of these officers, the first of them Morard de Galles, were actually dedicated to the Republic and its egalitarian principles – all the more, in fact, since they hoped that the advent of the Republic would fill the authority void caused by the collapse of the monarchy.Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p. 33 Others, such as Kerguelen or Lemarant-Boissauveur, had suffered humiliations from the naval establishment of the Ancien Régime, doubling the republican loyalty of their political convictions with personal resentment against the old order.Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p. 41 would carry revolutionary fervour and suspicion to the point of denouncing Lelarge and Morard de Galles as suspect, and be considered as paranoid by Jeanbon Saint-André.Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p. 42
On the other hand, officers enlisted from the merchant Navy felt insulted by the perceived arrogance of their comrades, and were suspicious as to the sincerity of their allegiance to the Republic. Captain Coëtnempren would be arrested and eventually sent to the guillotine upon a denunciation by a junior officer who accused him from withholding his advancement because he was a commoner from the merchant navy. Due to the desertions of high-ranking officers of noble extraction or Royalist convictions, these merchant officers were promoted very quickly to fill the ranks; this both transformed the social composition of naval staff, and promoted officers of little experience to command positions.
In January 1793, Morard de Galles was promoted to vice-admiral, and given overall command of the naval forces of Brest. Aware of the sorry state of his fleet, Morard de Galles wrote to the Committee of Public Safety to express his concerns, but was ignored.
France declared war on Great Britain on 1 February 1793, and very quickly, the British made contact with Royalist guerrilla forces in Vendée and Brittany. This made it necessary not only to protect French merchant convoys in the English Channel, but also to patrol the shores of France and prevent any potential British support from reaching the Chouans.Troude, vol. 2, p. 285
Events
On 8 March, Morard de Galles was ordered to take a 3-ship and 7-frigate division off Brest. Soon after their departure, a storm scattered the division and forced it back to harbour, where it arrived on 19. The same storm forced another division, under Captain Duval, to turn back; Duval had in fact died on Tourville, killed by a loose block when he attempted to secure a sail after his men had refused to obey his orders.Cormack, Revolution and Political Conflict, p.218Troude, vol.2, p.286
In mid-September, Captain Villaret-Joyeuse anchored the 74-guns Trajan and Jean Bart at Quibéron, to prevent communications between the British and the Chouans. These forces were soon deemed insufficient, and a flow of warships trickled from Brest, Lorient and Rochefort to reinforce Villaret's squadron. By 22 May, the forces in Quibéron were so considerable that Morard de Galles was sent to take command, with four more ships of the line;Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p.34 In June, the three-deckers Terrible and Bretagne prepared to depart under Rear-admiral Lelarge, but the crews refused to set sails and the officers had to request help from the municipalities to establish their authority over their own men. By early September 1793, Morard headed a squadron composed of 22 ships of the line and 13 frigates.Troude, vol.2, p.287
Morard's mission was two-fold: protect inbound convoys depredation of the Royal Navy; and establish a watch and blockade of those departments tempted by Chouannerie.Troude, vol.2, p.288 These instructions were in fact contradictory: protecting convoys entailed sailing in the open sea, while blockading the Chouans required ships as close to the shore as possible;Cormack, p.35 therefore, Morard could not fulfill both missions without splitting his forces, but from the station where he was ordered, off Quiberon, between Groix and Belle Île,Guérin, p.456 he could perform neither.Troude, vol.2, p.289 Morard wrote in vain to Navy commissioner Jean Dalbarade to argue for a blockade of the England shores instead. Rear-admiral Kerguelen wrote:Kerguelen, p.352
Morard repeatedly wrote to Dalbarade for clarification his orders, complaining that they "contradict[ed] themselves at each paragraph"; eventually he even requested to be replaced, but to no avail. On 10 August, a war council was held on Terrible, where all senior officers agreed that the state of the fleet was becoming critical and that it was urgent to sail back to Brest, but Dalbarade was unmoved.Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p.36
In early September, Morard received the third task of intercepting a Dutch convoy; this required to detach a five-ship division, thus dividing and exposing his forces. Before the division could depart, on 12 September, the crews were informed of the surrender of Toulon to a combined Anglo-Spanish force, and rumours started to spread that Brest herself was also in danger of being surrendered by Royalist conspirators; sailors began suspecting their officers of prolonging the cruise to communicate with the Chouans and Royalists. A deputation of the crews, composed of Midshipmen Crevel and Baron, from Auguste, went to see Morard, demanding that he set sail for Brest immediately.Guérin, p.457 Morard answered that he would only return upon orders from the government.
On 14 September, Morard discovered the topsails readied to depart on the ships Suffren, Tourville, Convention, Achille, Superbe, Auguste, Northumberland and Révolution. Considering that his officer could no longer exert their authority on their own crews, and fearing that a portion of his forces would depart and leave the rest even more exposed, Motart toured his least trustworthy ships with Kerguelen and ,Cormack, French Navy and the Struggle for Revolutionary Authority, p.37 and organised a council: in order to conciliate the men, a fleet summit would be held on Terrible, with all admirals and Captains present, and where each ship would be represented a seaman.
The council unanimously requested to return to Brest, but Morard read the orders of the Convention and gave a speech that convinced it to request further orders from the National Convention. It was decided that the squadron would set sail to escort a convoy that had been anchored for several days off Morbihan. The frigate Bellone, which escorted it, had run aground when arriving, and her crew had refused to execute orders, preventing her officers from refloating her. However, with his letter to the Convention, Morard had added that, since order would last only until favourable winds to the return to Brest, in order to maintain the pretence of authority, he was determined to return to Brest as soon as possible in any case.
The fleet departed on 19 September, as soon as the winds blew favourably. The next day, it met a frigate carrying deputy Tréhouart de Beaulieu, who was welcomed aboard and held another council. There again, it was determined that the fleet was in no condition to continue its mission and should return to Brest; Tréhouart ordered it made so, in the interest of the safety of the ship and of the pretence of command. The fleet arrived at Belle Île on 26, and in the road of Brest on 28 September.
Aftermath