Evan Mulrooney (born 1993) is an American actor, comedian, and former collegiate football player. He is known for season 5 of Only Murders in the Building (Hulu, 2025) and recurring roles on the television series Fargo (FX), Justified: City Primeval, and the sitcom South Side.
Early life and education Mulrooney grew up in Wilmington, Delaware, and attended the University of Maryland on a full football scholarship. He moved to Chicago in 2016 to pursue a career in comedy.
Career Stage and improv In Chicago, Mulrooney performed at Steppenwolf Theatre Company and is a member of the creative ensemble at The Annoyance Theatre. He acted in Shitfyre: The Musical. He also performed long‑form improv at iO Chicago.
Television Mulrooney’s television credits include recurring and guest appearances on Only Murders in the Building as Vinny Caccimelio, one of the sons of Sofia Caccimelio (Téa Leoni) who ended the season in a relationship with the character of Howard Morris
He appeared on RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars season 11 as a guest judge and returned for the finale as a Pit Crew member.
Film and commercial work Mulrooney’s film work includes a supporting role in Stop! That! Train! (2026) and the upcoming comedy What the F*ck Is My Password?. He has appeared in national commercials, most notably for Planet Fitness and Kia’s NBA All‑Star Weekend campaigns in 2022 and 2023.
Filmography Television Year Title Role Notes2026RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars season 11Guest JudgeEpisodes 10 and 12 2025 Only Murders in the Building (Season 5) Vinny Caccimelio Recurring (4 episodes) 2024 Fargo Joe Bulo Recurring (4 episodes) 2023 Justified: City Primeval Agron Darke Guest star 2022 South Side — Co‑star 2022 Dexter: Resurrection Dave Guest star (S1 Ep 110) 2021 Seal Team — Co‑star 2020 Chicago Fire Dwayne Guest (S8 Ep 17)
Film Year Title Role Notes TBD WTF Is My Password?! Feature film 2026 Stop That Train! Chet Feature film 2020 Start Without Me Supporting Feature film
Commercials Year Brand Role 2023 Planet Fitness National host 2023 Kia (NBA All‑Star Weekend) Comedy host 2022 Kia (NBA All‑Star Weekend) Comedy host
Personal life Mulrooney resides in Los Angeles, where he has trained with acting coaches Aaron Speiser and Kay Aston at The Screen Acting Studio. He creates comedic content on Instagram. Mulrooney identifies as queer and pansexual.
References