The 1958 Ontario Liberal Party leadership convention was held on April 20, 1958, at the King Edward Hotel in Toronto to elect a successor to Farquhar Oliver as leader of the Ontario Liberal Party. The convention elected John Wintermeyer, the Member of Provincial Parliament for Waterloo North, on the third ballot after he overcame a first-ballot lead by former federal finance minister Walter Harris.

The convention is notable as one of the few Canadian political leadership contests in which the first-ballot leader was defeated. Harris led on the opening ballot but was unable to secure sufficient support from delegates backing other candidates, many of whom subsequently rallied behind Wintermeyer.

Background

The Ontario Liberal Party entered the convention seeking to reverse more than a decade of political decline. Since losing office in the 1943 Ontario general election, the party had struggled to compete with the governing Progressive Conservatives. Oliver, who had led the party since 1954, announced his resignation, prompting a leadership contest among seven candidates.

The leading contenders included Harris, a former federal Minister of Finance in the government of Louis St. Laurent, and Wintermeyer, a Kitchener lawyer first elected to the Legislative Assembly of Ontario in 1955. Other candidates included former federal MP Joe Greene, MPP Vernon Singer, Ross Whicher, Arthur Reaume, and Albert Wren.

Campaign

Harris entered the convention as the frontrunner and represented the party establishment. Wintermeyer, by contrast, campaigned as a younger candidate capable of rebuilding the party and reconnecting it with Ontario voters. At age 41, he was viewed as representing a new generation of leadership.

Contemporary observers noted that delegates appeared determined to exert greater influence over both the party's leadership and organizational structure. Editorial commentary following the convention suggested that delegates had rejected excessive control by party insiders and were demanding renewal within the party.

Convention

The convention convened at Toronto's King Edward Hotel on April 20, 1958. Harris led the first ballot with 304 votes, followed by Wintermeyer with 264. Greene finished third with 88 votes.

Following the first ballot, Albert Wren was eliminated and endorsed Wintermeyer. Ross Whicher and Arthur Reaume subsequently withdrew and directed their delegates to support Wintermeyer. Their support enabled Wintermeyer to surpass Harris on the second ballot.

Contemporary reporting described the movement of delegates from the other candidates to Wintermeyer as a "Stop Walter Harris" effort among convention delegates unwilling to support Harris's candidacy.

Wintermeyer increased his lead on the third ballot and was elected leader before a record turnout of 761 voting delegates.

Results + Delegate support by ballot Candidate 1st ballot 2nd ballot 3rd ballot Votes % Votes % Votes % John Wintermeyer 264 34.2 369 46.8 398 53.3 Walter Harris 304 39.3 354 44.9 349 46.7 Joe Greene 88 11.4 45 5.7 14 1.9 Vernon Singer 43 5.6 21 2.7 Ross Whicher 39 5.0 Arthur Reaume 32 4.1 Albert Wren 7 0.9 Total 777 100.0 789 100.0 747 100.0

Aftermath

Wintermeyer's election was widely regarded as a generational shift within the Ontario Liberal Party. Contemporary commentary emphasized his youth, educational credentials, and professional background, while expressing hope that he could restore the party to a level of prominence not seen since the leadership of former premier Mitchell Hepburn.

Following the convention, Wintermeyer immediately called a caucus meeting to prepare for upcoming provincial by-elections and to begin developing a renewed party platform.

Under Wintermeyer's leadership, the Liberals improved their standing in the 1959 Ontario general election, increasing their caucus from 10 to 21 seats. Although Premier Leslie Frost retained a Progressive Conservative majority government, the election represented the party's strongest showing in many years.

Political commentators have subsequently cited the convention as a notable example of a delegated convention in which alliances among supporters of lower-ranked candidates overcame the initial advantage held by the frontrunner.

References