Goodbye Horses is the second mixtape by American rapper Ian, released on October 18, 2024, through BuVision and Columbia Records. The album follows Ian's debut mixtape Valedictorian (2024), and includes guest appearances from Chief Keef, Lil Yachty, Eyesis, and Reign.
Reception
HotNewHipHop noted the controversy of the previous release and asked its readers how they felt about the mixtape, including the presence of guest artists Chief Keef and Lil Yachty.
The Needle Drop sharply criticized the mixtape, saying its "core content... sucks." Reviewer Anthony Fantano pointed to "On the Floor" as the only "listenable" song in an mixtape that is "the definition of mid."
Track listing
Personnel Credits adapted from Tidal. Ian – vocals (all tracks); engineering, mixing, mastering (tracks 1–10, 12, 13) Nicco "Neek" Catalano – mixing, mastering (1–10, 12, 13) Lil Yachty – vocals (11) Benjamin Mathew – engineering, mixing (11) Colin Leonard – mastering (11)
Personnel These credits have been adapted from Tidal:
Ian Smith – recording, mixing, mastering (except "Hate Me") Nicco "Neek" Catalano – mixing, mastering (except "Hate Me") Benjamin Mathew – recording, mixing ("Hate Me") Colin Leonard – mastering ("Hate Me")
Charts + Chart performance for Goodbye Horses Chart (2024) Peakposition US Billboard 200 86
References