An All-American team is an honorary sports team composed of the best amateur players of a specific season for each team position—who in turn are given the honorific "All-America" and typically referred to as "All-American athletes", or simply "All-Americans". Although the honorees generally do not compete together as a unit, the term is used in U.S. team sports to refer to players who are selected by members of the national media. Walter Camp selected the first All-America team in the early days of American football in 1889. The 2023 NCAA Men's Soccer All-Americans are honorary lists that include All-American selections from the United Soccer Coaches (USC), Top Drawer Soccer (TDS), Soccer America (TSN), and College Soccer News for the 2023 NCAA Division I men's soccer season. All selectors choose at least a first, second, and third 11-man team.
Although the aforementioned lists are used to determine consensus honors, there are numerous other All-American lists. The three finalists for the Hermann Trophy are described as Hermann All-Americans. The scholar-athletes selected by College Sports Information Directors of America (CoSIDA) are termed Academic All-Americans.
Individual All-America teams
By player This list is of players who were named first-team All-Americans by each respective publication.
Key
CSNCollege Soccer NewsTDSTop Drawer SoccerUSCUnited Soccer Coaches *Consensus All-American (selected by all selectors)Awarded the Hermann Trophy as national Player of the Year
List
PositionNameSchoolCSNTDSUSCNotesForward*MarshallSBC Player of the YearMidfielderStanfordDefender*PortlandWCC Defender of the YearMidfielder*New HampshireAm. East Midfielder of the YearHermann Trophy finalistForwardWest VirginiaForwardHofstraGoalkeeper*Notre DameTDS National Player of the YearACC Goalkeeper of the YearDefenderMarshallSBC Defensive Player of the YearForwardOregon StatePac-12 Player of the YearMidfielderHofstraCAA Player of the YearDefenderGeorgetownBig East Defender of the YearForwardCharlotteForward *Western MichiganMVC Player of the YearHermann Trophy finalistForwardAkronBig East Forward of the YearForwardLipscombASUN Player of the Year2024 MLS SuperDraft No. 1 pickMidfielder*ClemsonHermann Trophy winnerForwardWest VirginiaDefender *Wake ForestACC Defender of the YearDefenderSMUAAC Defender of the Year
By team All-America Team First team Second team Third teamPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolCollege Soccer News Charlie SharpWestern Michigan Tyrese SpicerLipscomb Alec HughesUMass Marcus CaldeiraWest Virginia Ryan CarmichaelHofstra Taylor CalheiraUMBC Matthew BellMarshall Peter MangionePenn State Samuel SarverIndiana Jason ShokalookAkron Logan FarringtonOregon State Dylan SingWestern Michigan Yannick BrightNew Hampshire Yutaro TsukadaWest Virginia Jelldrik DallmanSMU Eliot GoldthorpHofstra Sam BassettDenver James MorrisSeattle U Ousmane SyllaClemson Zach BohaneStanford David JacksonNavy Kevin BonillaPortland Mason TunbridgeSan Diego Tucker LepleyUCLA Garrison TubbsWake Forest Jaylen ShannonWestern Michigan Jack DentonMissouri State Kenny NielsenGeorgetown Morris DugganMarshall Jeorgio KocevskiSyracuse Bryan DowdNotre Dame Mads WestergrenSMU Griffin RoachBoston University Cole JohnsonSMU Finn McRobbHigh Point Kiergan SargeantGeorgetown Joseba InceraNew HampshireTop Drawer Soccer Bryan Dowd Notre Dame Mouhameth Thiam Virginia Tucker LepleyUCLA Ousmane Sylla Clemson Tyrese Spicer Lipscomb Dylan SingWestern Michigan Logan FarringtonOregon State Eliot GoldthorpHofstra Foster AjagoDuke Matthew BellMarshall Sam BassettDenver Jeorgio KocevskiSyracuse Zach BohaneStanford Femi AwodesuPenn State Jonathan RobinsonWestern Michigan Garrison TubbsWake Forest Jelldrik DallmanSMU Hugo BacharachIndiana Charlie SharpWestern Michigan Bryce BoneauNotre Dame Wyatt MeyerCalifornia Morris DugganMarshall Isaac NehmeDenver Brandon ParrishClemson Kevin Bonilla Portland Mads Westergren SMU Cole JohnsonSMU Ryan CarmichaelHofstra Kenny NielsenGeorgetown Jason ShokalookAkron Yannick Bright New Hampshire Hesron Barry Green Bay Luis FloresOral Roberts Yutaro Tsukada West Virginia Alec Hughes UMass Marcus CaldeiraWest VirginiaUnited Soccer Coaches Bryan Dowd Notre Dame Cole Johnson SMU Joseba InceraNew Hampshire Kevin Bonilla Portland Kiergan Sargeant Georgetown Javier ArmasOregon State Morris DugganMarshall Kenny NielsenGeorgetown Hesron BarryGreen Bay Garrison TubbsWake Forest Jaylen ShannonWestern Michigan Pierce InfusoHofstra Mads WestergrenSMU Sam BassettDenver Nick FernandezPortland Yannick Bright New Hampshire Bailey Sparks SMU Tucker LepleyUCLA Eliot Goldthorp Hofstra Mason Tunbridge San Diego Taimu OkiyoshiMarshall Jono Nyandjo Charlotte Foster Ajago Duke Logan FarringtonOregon State Matthew BellMarshall Marcus CaldeiraWest Virginia Stephen Annor GyamfiVirginia Charlie SharpWestern Michigan Ryan CarmichaelHofstra Quenzi HuermanNorth Carolina Tyrese SpicerLipscomb Jelldrik DallmanSMU Lineker RodriguesMemphis Ousmane SyllaClemson Jason ShokalookAkron Samuel SarverIndiana Yutaro TsukadaWest Virginia
Academic All-Americans All-America Team First team Second team Third teamPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolCoSIDA Ethan BrandtWestern Michigan J.T. HarmsIndiana Gabriel MikinaSyracuse Tommy SilvaUCLA Nolan PremackCal Baptist Lasse KelpUMBC Jason BelloliDenver Ethan AshNorth Florida Diego KonincksSaint Louis Youri SendenDrexel Sam BjörkSeton Hall Hesron BarryGreen Bay Wyatt MeyerCalifornia Paddy BurnsNotre Dame Jonathan StoutMichigan State Marc TorrellasLoyola Chicago Joey MaherIndiana Timo HummrichFordham Brendan HerbUNC Asheville Ask EkelandDuquesne Zach BohaneStanford Nick ParianoDuke Mark FisherStanford Alessandro ArlottiHarvard Dylan SingWestern Michigan Will ReillyStanford Victor ClaudelFlorida Atlantic Jelldrik DallmanSMU Charlie SharpWestern Michigan Peter MangionePenn State Marcus Caldeira West Virginia Nicholas ChateauSt. John's Nick Zielonka UMass Alfie PopeCreighton United Soccer Coaches Francesco MontaliBoston University Nick ChristoffersenPenn Pierce InfusoHofstra Jackson LeeWest Virginia Griffin RoachBoston University Ryan ScheweGeorgetown Tommy SilvaUCLA Wessell SpeelHofstra Garrison TubbsWake Forest Jonas BuechteAkron Yannick BrightNew Hampshire Brock PopeBellarmine Mark FisherStanford Riley ThomasNorth Carolina Bilal KamalNew Hampshire Christian BuendiaSaint Louis Eli GoldmanNew Hampshire Collin McCamyNorthwestern Joey MaherIndiana Peter MangionePenn State Charlie SharpWestern Michigan Dylan SingWestern Michigan Yutaro TsukadaWest Virginia Justin WeissNorthwestern
Freshman All-Americans
All-America Team First team Second team Third teamPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolPlayer SchoolCollege Soccer News Alex Harris Cornell Kimani Stewart-Baynes Maryland Ryan OkerayiHouston Christian Stephen Annor Gyamfi Virginia Collins Oduro Indiana Victor Faaborg ChristensenPresbyterian Úlfur Björnsson Duke Marco Silva Marshall Noeh HernandezDePaul Barzee Blama Mercer Saad Chaouki Rider Saku HeiskanenUCF Joshua SaavedraLIU Donovan PhillipOakland Efetobo ArorPortland Liam O'GaraWake Forest Richard MonathDelaware Niv BerkovitzSMU Noah JamesWestern Michigan Miles BonhamDayton Martin Kwende Jr. Santa Clara Luca NikolaiJames Madison Arthur DuquenneClemson Drew HardinCal Baptist Reid FisherSan Diego State Kieran ChandlerUConn Chris OgorLoyola (MD) Nick LockermannVermont Will EbyMichigan State Fritz VolmarNorthwestern Pape Mar Boye Clemson Rowan Schnebly Stanford Aidan CrawfordLoyola Chicago Julian EyestoneDuke Pearse O'BrienProvidence Jakub GrzesiakOral RobertsTop Drawer Soccer Alex Harris Cornell Arthur Duquenne Clemson Rai PintoMarshall Pape Mar Boye Clemson Collins Oduro Indiana Saku HeiskanenUCF Stephen Annor GyamfiVirginia Caden GrabfelderPenn State Reid FisherSan Diego State Liam O'GaraWake Forest Miles BonhamDayton Alex BargerIndiana Julian EyestoneDuke Nick LockermannVermont Jakub GrzesiakOral Roberts Luca NikolaiJames Madison Dylan HooperStanford Kieran ChandlerUConn Noah JamesWestern Michigan Pearse O'BrienProvidence Fritz VolmarNorthwestern Úlfur BjörnssonDuke Marco SilvaMarshall Nathan RodriguesLoyola Marymount Joshua Saavedra LIU Kimani Stewart-Baynes Maryland Aidan CrawfordLoyola Chicago Noeh Hernandez DePaul Saad Chaouki Rider Niv BerkovitzSMU Will Eby Michigan State Rowan Schnebly Stanford Richard MonathDelaware
References