Clare Caitlin McNulty (born October 15, 1984) is an American actress. She is best known for playing Allie in the independent comedy film Fort Tilden (2014) and Chantal Witherbottom on the HBO Max dark comedy television series Search Party (2016–2022).

Biography Born on October 15, 1984, Clare Caitlin McNulty is the daughter of Michael and Linda McNulty. She grew up in Tucson, Arizona. She graduated from University High School in Tucson and attended Oberlin College, where she met Sarah-Violet Bliss, and graduated in 2007. Her interest in acting began when she participated in a theater workshop while she was a high-school student. She is the granddaughter of James F. McNulty Jr., who was a U. S. Congressman from Arizona.

McNulty, an award-winning soprano, sang with the Tucson Girls Chorus when she was in high school.

As of 2015, McNulty resides in Ditmas Park, Brooklyn. In 2022, she signed with Key Talent Management.

Fort Tilden, in which McNulty starred, won the Grand Jury Award at the 2014 SXSW Film Festival.

Acting credits Film Year Title Role 2014 Fort Tilden Allie 2016 Mad Dr. Bolden 2019 We Used to Know Each Other

Television Year Title Role Notes 2014 High Maintenance Actress 1 episode 2016–2022 Search Party Chantal Witherbottom 27 episodes 2024 The Conners Amanda 1 episode Night Court Layla 1 episode Loot Louise 1 episode 2025 Platonic Dr. Rapaport Episode: "Fore!"

Theater Year Title Role Venue 2014 Powerhouse Mitzi New Ohio Theatre

References

External links