The Oakdale Handicap was an American Thoroughbred horse race run in twenty-four years between 1902 and 1932 at Aqueduct Racetrack in Ozone Park, New York. A six furlong event run in the fall, it was open for two-year-old horses of either sex. Fillies won it in 1905, 1924, and 1927.
Historical notes First run on November 7, 1902, the distance for that year only was set at seven furlongs. It was won by Lyman Hay, a colt owned by Charles Ellison and trained by John Mayberry. The owner and trainer had hoped Lyman Hay might be a "Derby" horse for 1903. He was not, but as luck would have it they had Judge Himes in their stable with which they would win the 1903 Kentucky Derby.
Hart-Agnew Law interruption The 1908 passage of the Hart-Agnew anti-betting legislation by the New York Legislature under Republican Governor Charles Evans Hughes led to a state-wide shutdown of racing in 1911 and 1912. A February 21, 1913 ruling by the New York Supreme Court, Appellate Division saw horse racing return in 1913. However, the Oakdale Handicap was not restored to the track's schedule until 1917.
Grey Lag's loss The biggest upset in the history of the Oakdale occurred in 1920 when J. D. Mooney rode Knobbie to victory over Grey Lag. A recent purchase by trainer Sam Hildreth for the Rancocas Stable, Grey Lag's career would see him earn four National Champion titles, including American Horse of the Year, and induction into the U.S. Racing Hall of Fame.The Bloodhorse.com Champion's history charts racingmuseum.org Grey Lag
A casualty of the Great Depression The Wall Street crash of 1929 marked the beginning of the Great Depression, the effects of which saw racetrack owners and all businesses across the United States scrambling to reduce costs to prevent closing. Aqueduct Racetrack would begin shuffling its races to cut purse money for some in order to enhance it for others. While the September 18, 1929 Oakdale was modified to claiming race status, it maintained its purse money until the economic downturn became so severe they had to cut the purse for the 1931 edition by 35% and for 1932 that new lower amount was cut in half. Still not enough to ensure the track's survival, the Oakdale had to be dropped from the fall schedule.
Records Speed record: 1:12.00 @ 6 furlongs: Ray Jay (1921) 1:12.00 @ 6 furlongs: Sarazen (1923) 1:12.00 @ 6 furlongs: Teheran (1926)
Most wins by a jockey: no jockey won this race more than once.
Most wins by a trainer: 5 – James E. Fitzsimmons (1920, 1921, 1924, 1927, 1931)
Most wins by an owner: 2 – Harry Payne Whitney (1907, 1930) 2 – Quincy Stable (James Francis Johnson) (1920, 1921) 2 – Belair Stud Stable (1924, 1931)
Winners Year Winner Age Jockey Trainer Owner (Furlongs) Time Win $1932Garden Message2George H. BostwickJ. P. (Sammy) SmithGeorge H. Bostwick6 f1:12.80$1,4251931Pardee2Tommy MalleyJames E. FitzsimmonsBelair Stud Stable6 f1:13.40$3,0501930Smear2Alfred M. RobertsonJames G. Rowe Jr.Harry Payne Whitney6 f1:13.20$4,6251929Martis2Charles KurtsingerFrank J. KearnsWalter Schuttler6 f1:14.00$4,3751928Calwick2Frank MoonJohn HastingsGeorge M. Sidenberg6 f1:12.60$4,4501927Nixie2Phil GoodwinJames E. FitzsimmonsWheatley Stable6 f1:12.60$4,7751926Teheran2John MaibenT. J. HealeyWalter J. Salmon Sr.6 f1:12.00$4,7501925Sarmaticus2Frank ColtilettiGeorge P. OdomRobert L. Gerry6 f1:13.40$4,0751924Beatrice2George FieldsJames E. FitzsimmonsBelair Stud Stable6 f1:12.60$4,6501923Sarazen2Clarence KummerMax HirschFair Stable6 f1:12.00$4,5001922Runviso2Clifford RobinsonJohnny LoftusOak Ridge Stable6 f1:12.20$2,5501921Ray Jay2Linus McAteeJames E. FitzsimmonsQuincy Stable (James Francis Johnson) 6 f1:12.00$4,7001920Knobbie2J. D. MooneyJames E. FitzsimmonsQuincy Stable (James Francis Johnson)6 f1:13.00$4,0251919Krewer2Laverne FatorSamuel C. HildrethSamuel C. Hildreth6 f1:13.00$2,6251918Eternal2Andy SchuttingerKimball PattersonJames W. McClelland6 f1:14.40$1,8251917Lanius2John McTaggartA. Jack JoynerGeorge D. Widener Jr.6 f1:13.20$1,7551910 – 1916 Race not held1909Hampton Court2Guy GarnerJohn E. MaddenJohn E. Madden6 f1:14.00$1908 Race not held1907Royal Tourist2Walter MillerJohn W. RogersHarry Payne Whitney6 f1:14.00$1,5551906Stray2R McDanielMatthew ByrnesMatthew Byrnes6 f1:14.00$1,5801905Flip Flap2Roche RomanelliA. J. GoldsboroughJack A. Bennet6 f1:14.40$1,7451904Jim Beattie2William CrimminsT. J. SlatteryC. A. lnwick6 f1:14.80$1,2101903Dick Turpin2Harry CochranFrank ReganFrank Regan6 f1:13.40$1,2251902Lyman Hay2Lucien LyneJohn P. MayberryCharles R. Ellison7 f1:28.00$1,130
References