Justice Carpenter may refer to:
Alonzo P. Carpenter (1829–1898), associate justice of the New Hampshire Supreme Court Elisha Carpenter (1824–1897), associate justice of the Connecticut Supreme Court George Moulton Carpenter Jr. (1844–1896), associate justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court Thomas Preston Carpenter (1804–1876), associate justice of the Supreme Court of New Jersey
See also Judge Carpenter (disambiguation)