Contaminants of emerging concern (CEC) is a term used by water quality professionals to describe pollutants that have been detected in environmental monitoring samples, that may cause ecological or human health impacts, and typically are not regulated under current environmental laws. Sources of these pollutants include agriculture, urban runoff and ordinary household products (such as soaps and disinfectants) and pharmaceuticals that are disposed to sewage treatment plants and subsequently discharged to surface waters.
CEC include different substances like pharmaceuticals, personal care products, industrial byproducts, and agricultural chemicals. These substances often bypass regular detection and treatment processes, leading to their unintended persistence in the environment. The complexity of CEC arises not only from their different chemical nature but also from the complex ways they interact with ecosystems and human health. As such, they are the focus of increasing examination by researchers, policymakers, and public health officials who want to understand their long-term effects and develop effective interventions. Global initiatives, like those from the World Health Organization (WHO) and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), emphasize the need to create international standards and effective environmental policies to address the challenges posed by CEC. Public awareness and advocacy play crucial roles in driving the research agenda and policy development for CEC, highlighting the need for updated manufacturing practices and developing more remediation and detection methods.
History and background The concept of CEC gained significant attention in the early 21st century as advances in analytical techniques such as liquid chromatography - mass spectrometry (LC-MS) and gas chromatography - mass spectrometry (GC-MS) allowed for the detection of these substances at trace levels in various environmental matrices. These sophisticated tools enabled scientists to detect trace concentrations of previously overlooked chemicals in various environmental matrices including wastewater, surface water, groundwater and even drinking water samples. The increased awareness of CEC is partly due to their abundant presence in wastewater, surface water, groundwater, and drinking water, often because of urbanization, industrial activities, and the widespread use of pharmaceuticals and personal care products. The recognition of the potential risks posed by CEC has led to a growing body of research aimed at understanding their sources, fate, and effects in the environment, as well as the development of strategies for their management and removal.
Past events
In the 19th and early 20th centuries asbestos was used in many products and in building construction and was not considered a threat to human health or the environment. Deaths and lung problems caused by asbestos were first documented in the early 20th century. The first regulations of the asbestos industry were published in the UK in the 1930s. Regulation of asbestos in the US did not occur until the 1980s. In the 1970s there was a serious issue with the water treatment infrastructure of some US states, notably in Southern California with water sourced from the Sacramento–San Joaquin River Delta. Water was being disinfected for domestic use through chlorine treatment, which was effective for killing microbial contaminants and bacteria, but in some cases, it reacted with runoff chemicals and organic matter to form trihalomethanes (THMs). Research done in the subsequent years began to suggest the carcinogenic and harmful nature of this category of compounds. EPA issued its first standard for THMs, applicable to public water systems, in 1979, and more stringent standards in 1998 and 2006. Rapid industry changes also make the treatment and regulation of CEC particularly challenging. For instance, the replacing substance (GenX), for the recently regulated perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), a PFAS, had a more detrimental environmental impact, resulting in the subsequently banning of GenX as well. Hence, there is a pressing need for the treatment and management of CEC to keep up with global trends.
Classification For a compound to be recognized as an emerging contaminant it has to meet at least two requirements: Adverse human health effects have been associated with a compound. There is an established relationship between the positive and negative effect(s) of the compound. Emerging contaminants are those which have not previously been detected through water quality analysis, or have been found in small concentrations with uncertainty as to their effects. The risk they pose to human or environmental health is not fully understood.
Contaminant classes Contaminants of emerging concern (CEC) can be broadly classed into several categories of chemicals such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products, cyanotoxins, nanoparticles, and flame retardants, among others. However, these classifications are constantly changing as new contaminants (or effects) are discovered and emerging contaminants from past years become less of a priority. These contaminants can generally be categorized as truly "new" contaminants that have only recently been discovered and researched, contaminants that were known about but their environmental effects were not fully understood, or "old" contaminants that have new information arising regarding their risks.
Pharmaceuticals Pharmaceuticals are gaining more attention as Contaminants of emerging concern (CECs) because of their continual release into the environment, their persistence and their general lack of regulation. These compounds are often present at low concentrations in water bodies and little is currently known about their environmental and health effects from chronic exposure; pharmaceuticals are only now becoming a focus in toxicology due to improved analytical techniques that allow very low concentrations to be detected. The main source of pharmaceutical pollution in the environment is effluent from wastewater treatment plants, aquaculture and agricultural runoffs.
Once present in the environment, pharmaceuticals can cause long-term ecological and health effects such as synthetic estrogens from contraceptives that have led to feminization in male fish, and anti-inflammatory drugs Despite their ubiquity in the environment, pharmaceuticals remain largely unregulated in most environmental statutes.
Personal care products Personal care products often contain a complex mixture of chemicals such as preservatives (e.g., parabens), UV filters (e.g., oxybenzone), plasticizers (e.g., phthalates), antimicrobials (e.g., triclosan), fragrances, and colorants. Many of these compounds are synthesized chemicals that are not typically found in nature. Chemicals from personal care products can enter the environment through various pathways. After use, they are often washed down the drain and can end up in the wastewater stream. These substances are not all completely removed by conventional wastewater treatment processes, leading to their release into natural water bodies. Some of these chemicals are persistent in the environment and can bioaccumulate in the tissues of organisms, potentially causing ecological disruptions. They can also have endocrine-disrupting properties that interfere with the hormonal systems of wildlife and humans.
Cyanotoxins In recent years, there has been an increase of cyanobacterial blooms due to the eutrophication (or increase in nutrient levels) of surface waters around the world. Increases in certain nutrients, such as nitrogen and phosphorus, are linked to fertilizer runoff from agricultural fields, and are also found in certain products, such as detergents, in urban spaces. These blooms can release toxins that can decrease water quality and are a risk to human and wildlife health. Additionally, there are a lack of regulations regarding the maximum contaminant levels (MCL) allowed in drinking water sources. Cyanotoxins can have both acute and chronic toxic effects, and there are often many consequences for the health of the environment where these blooms occur.
Industrial chemicals Industrial chemicals from various industries produce harmful chemicals that are known to cause harm to human health and the environment. Common industrial chemicals, like 1,4-Dioxanes, Perfluorooctane sulfonate (PFOS) and Perfluorooctanoic acid (PFOA), are commonly found in various water sources.
Nanomaterials Nanomaterials include carbon-based materials, metal oxides, metals, and quantum dots. Nanomaterials can enter the environment during their manufacturing, consumer use, or disposal. Due to their small size, nanomaterials behave differently than larger particles. They have a high surface area to volume ratio, which can lead to increased reactivity and the potential to transport throughout the environment. Nanomaterials are challenging to detect and monitor due to their size and the absence of standardized methods for measuring their presence and concentration in various media.
Sources and pathways
Agricultural runoff
Agricultural runoff is a major pathway through which CEC enter the environment. Compounds like pesticides and pharmaceuticals from fertilizers are carried by water from farms into their surrounding areas soil and water bodies. Then runoff happens after rainfall or irrigation, which causes an influx of chemicals to leak out of the soil where they were dumped and into rivers, lakes, and groundwater. The runoff can contain a CEC's which are not regulated or whose environmental impacts are not well understood, contributing to the pollution of aquatic ecosystems, and potentially affecting human water sources. A significant challenge is monitoring levels of CEC in bodies of water. A nationwide survey revealed that soil erosion, nutrient loss, and pesticide runoff from America's vast agricultural lands are leading causes of water quality pollution. Approximately 46% of rivers and streams in the United States have conditions which are harmful to aquatic life. Additionally, only about 28% of these water bodies are rated as 'healthy' based on their biological communities.
Industrial discharge Industrial discharge is when waste products are released into the environment from manufacturing and chemical processing facilities. This waste can include a wide variety of CEC like heavy metals, solvents, and various organic compounds that are not regularly detected for or removed by standard treatment processes. These contaminants can accumulate in sediments and biota, posing risks to aquatic life and human health. The complexity and diversity of industrial discharge requires advanced treatment technologies and stricter regulatory frameworks to prevent CEC from contaminating the environment. Advanced oxidation processes and membrane technologies have been researched and shown to reduce CEC from industrial discharge, however there is an excessive cost to retrofit existing treatment facilities with this technology.
Urban runoff Urban runoff is rainwater that runs through streets, gardens, and other urban surfaces, picking up various pollutants along the way. These pollutants can include CEC like microplastics from synthetic materials, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) from vehicle exhausts, and pharmaceuticals from improperly disposed medications. This untreated runoff can enter storm drains and eventually discharge into natural water bodies, often bypassing wastewater treatment facilities and leading to their accumulation in the environment, where they can cause harm to wildlife and potentially enter the human food chain. Permeable pavements and rain gardens are being implemented and tested in some urban areas to mitigate the effects of runoff, helping to filter pollutants before they reach the water system.
Wastewater treatment plants