Justice Paine may refer to:
Bayard H. Paine (1872–1955), associate justice of the Nebraska Supreme Court Byron Paine (1827–1871), associate justice of the Wisconsin Supreme Court Elijah Paine (1757–1842), associate justice of the Vermont Supreme Court Robert Treat Paine (1731–1814), associate justice of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court
See also Justice Pain (1978–2020), American professional wrestler Elisha Payne (1731–1807), chief justice of the Supreme Court of Vermont Judge Payne (disambiguation)