Justice Reynolds may refer to:
Charles H. Reynolds (1924–1996), associate justice of the Kentucky Supreme Court Frank B. Reynolds (1874–1922), associate justice of the Montana Supreme Court John Reynolds (Illinois politician) (1788–1865), associate justice of the Illinois Supreme Court Joseph Reynolds (Rhode Island) (1748–1818), associate justice of the Rhode Island Supreme Court Thomas Reynolds (governor) (1796–1844), chief justice of the Illinois Supreme Court