Andrew James Holmes (born November 14, 1989, in California) is an American actor, singer and composer working in musical theater, and a member of StarKid Productions.
He is known primarily for playing the role of Elder Cunningham in The Book of Mormon on Broadway, the US tour, the West End, Melbourne and Sydney. Holmes is also a member of StarKid Productions, having composed music for four of the theatre company's shows and acted in four of them. He was the sole composer of Twisted, leading him to be most closely identified with that musical.
Early life Holmes grew up in Southern California and graduated from University of Michigan in 2011.
Career While still in college, Holmes was a founding member of StarKid Productions, co-composing the music for their first show in 2009, A Very Potter Musical, where he also was credited as the music director and played the piano in the pit orchestra. Holmes then reprised his role as co-composer, music director, and pianist for Me and My Dick later that year, as well as playing the acting role of Joey's Heart.
After graduating, Holmes was cast as Frederick Frankenstein in the US national tour of Young Frankenstein. Holmes played this role from September 30, 2011, to May 31, 2012.
In 2012, Holmes returned to StarKid for A Very Potter Senior Year. He served as co-composer, musical director, and keyboard 1 in the pit orchestra, as well as playing the role of Gilderoy Lockhart.
In 2013, Holmes was the standby for Elder Cunningham on The Book of Mormon in the Chicago, Illinois production. He also composed the music for StarKid's Twisted alongside Kaley McMahon, who wrote the lyrics.
In 2013–2014, Holmes played Cunningham on the first national tour of The Book of Mormon.
In 2014, Holmes transferred to the Broadway production of The Book of Mormon as a standby for Cunningham from January 14, 2014, to June 29, 2014. From July 28, 2014, to January 31, 2015, he played the role in the West End production of the show, replacing Jared Gertner.
In 2015–2016, Holmes embarked on the second national tour of The Book of Mormon, again reprising his role as Elder Cunningham. He played this role from February 13, 2015, to May 1, 2016.
In 2017–2018, Holmes continued playing Elder Cunningham in The Book of Mormon. He originated the role in Melbourne from its opening on January 17, 2017, until his departure on June 25, 2017. Holmes returned to the role when the production moved to the Sydney Lyric theater on February 28, 2018. Holmes departed the production on September 9, 2018.
In 2025, Holmes played Jeff in the ACT production of Nobody Loves You from February 25 to March 30, 2025.
Credits Actor YearTitleRole Category 2009Me and My DickJoey's HeartUniversity of Michigan 2011Starship Starship Captain (cameo)Chicago 2011–2012Young FrankensteinFrederick Frankenstein U.S. tour 2012A Very Potter Senior YearGilderoy Lockhart LeakyCon2013The Book of MormonElder Cunningham (standby)Chicago 2013–2014Elder Cunningham First U.S. national tour 2014Elder Cunningham (standby)Broadway 2014–2015Elder CunninghamWest End 2015–2016 Second U.S. national tour 2017–2018 Australia national tour2016Bubble BoyJimmy2020Spies Are Forever The Deadliest Man Alive / Richard Big / EnsembleFeinstein's/54 Below concert; cancelled due to COVID-19 pandemicA VHS Christmas CarolFezziwigLivestreamed performance2021VHS Christmas Carol Live!Los Angeles2022Young FrankensteinFrederick Frankenstein La Mirada Theatre, CA Spies Are Forever Susan / Ensemble / Vanger Borschtit Feinstein's/54 Below Concert; reschedule of cancelled 2020 show20232024 VHS Christmas CarolsScroogeApollo Theatre, Chicago2025Nobody Loves YouJeffAmerican Conservatory Theater, San Francisco
Music Year Title Contribution2009 A Very Potter Musical Composer, music director, piano Me and My Dick Composer, music director, piano 2012 A Very Potter Senior Year Composer, music director, keyboard 1 2013 Twisted Composer
References
External links
Official Twitter