This is a list of seasons and results of collegiate ice hockey seasons since the inception of the NCAA tournament in 1947.

Tournament play begins Though U.S. colleges had been fielding men's ice hockey teams since 1894, the NCAA did not have a formal tournament in place to decide a champion until after World War II. Starting with the 1947–48 season, the NCAA tournament invited the four top-ranked teams to Colorado Springs, Colorado to compete for the NCAA Championship.

No. Season Tournament No. of teamsin tournament Start Finish NCAA champion(number) Championconference Championrecord Championship site 11947–481948 4 March 20 None(20–2–1)Colorado Springs, Colorado 21948–491949 4 March 19 None(21–1–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado 31949–5019504March 18 None(18–5–1)Colorado Springs, Colorado 41950–511951 4 March 17 (2) None(22–4–1)Colorado Springs, Colorado 51951–5219524March 15 (3) MCHL(22–4–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado 61952–5319534March 14 (4) MCHL(22–4–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado 71953–5419544March 13 Tri-State League(18–5–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado 81954–5519554March 12 (5) WIHL(18–5–1)Colorado Springs, Colorado 91955–5619564March 17 (6) WIHL(20–2–1)Colorado Springs, Colorado 101956–5719574March 16 (2) WIHL(25–5–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado

Rotating tournaments After spending 10 years at one location, the NCAA began to move the Division I ice hockey tournament to different sites. Over the next 14 years, the tournament was held in 11 different venues and, more importantly to the northeast teams, was held in New England eight times. While the rotations stopped briefly in 1972, they resumed after 1974, and the tournament has not been held in the same city for consecutive years since.

No. Season Tournament No. of teamsin tournament Start Finish NCAA champion(number) Championconference Championrecord Championship site 111957–5819584March 15 WIHL(25–10–2)Minneapolis, Minnesota 121958–5919594March 14 None(20–10–1)Troy, New York 131959–601960 4 March 19 (2) WCHA(27–4–3)Boston, Massachusetts 141960–6119614March 18 (3) WCHA(30–1–1)Denver, Colorado 151961–6219624March 17 WCHA(29–3–0)Utica, New York 161962–6319634March 16 (2) WCHA(22–7–3)Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts 171963–6419644March 21 (7) WCHA(24–4–1)Denver, Colorado 181964–65 19654March 20 (2) WCHA(24–5–2)Providence, Rhode Island 191965–66 19664March 19 WCHA(16–13–0)Minneapolis, Minnesota 201966–67 19674March 18 ECAC(27–1–1)Syracuse, New York 211967–68 19684March 16 (4) WCHA(28–5–1)Duluth, Minnesota 221968–69 19694March 15 (5) WCHA(26–6–0)Colorado Springs, Colorado 231969–70 19704March 21 (2) ECAC(29–0–0)Lake Placid, New York 241970–71 19714March 20 ECAC(28–2–1)Syracuse, New York 251971–72 19724March 18 (2) ECAC(26–4–1)Boston, Massachusetts 261972–73 1973 4 March 17 WCHA(29–9–2)Boston, Massachusetts 271973–7419744March 16 WCHA(22–11–6)Boston, Massachusetts 281974–7519754March 15 (3) WCHA(32–10–0)St. Louis, Missouri 291975–7619764March 27 (2) WCHA(28–14–2)Denver, Colorado

Quarterfinals expansion For the 30th season of the tournament, which had become the de facto possession of the WCHA and ECAC, the NCAA instituted a new rule by which they were able to add up to four additional teams to the tournament if they saw fit. This policy essentially became a vehicle allowing the CCHA champion to play, with the lone exception coming in 1978. For the 1981 tournament, the NCAA altered the rule to guarantee a full quarterfinal round, and started including true 'at large' teams for the first time. Between 1981 and 1987, the quarterfinals consisted of two games, where the team that scored the most goals in the two games would advance to the "Frozen Four". Between 1977 and 1987, Detroit, Michigan and Providence, Rhode Island would each host the tournament four times.

No. Season Tournament No. of teamsin tournament Start Finish NCAA champion(number) Championconference Championrecord Championship site 301976–7719775March 26 (2) WCHA(37–7–1)Detroit, Michigan 311977–7819786March 25 (3) ECAC(30–2–0)Providence, Rhode Island 321978–7919795March 24 (3) WCHA(32–11–1)Detroit, Michigan 331979–8019805March 29 (3) WCHA(31–8–1)Providence, Rhode Island 341980–8119818March 28 (3) WCHA(27–14–1)Duluth, Minnesota 351981–8219828March 27 (4) WCHA(35–12–0)Providence, Rhode Island 361982–8319838March 26 (4) WCHA(33–10–4)Grand Forks, North Dakota 371983–8419848March 24 CCHA(34–8–2)Lake Placid, New York 381984–851985 8 March 30 (2) ECAC(35–2–1)Detroit, Michigan 391985–8619868March 29 (2) CCHA(34–9–2)Providence, Rhode Island 401986–8719878March 28 (5) WCHA(40–8–0)Detroit, Michigan

Additional expansion With four major conferences and a myriad of independent programs competing at the Division I level, the tournament was expanded to 12 teams beginning with the 1987–88 season. The first round followed the same pattern as the quarterfinals, with teams playing two games against a single opponent, and the one with a higher goal total after the series advancing. The rest of the tournament retained the earlier format. One year later, the goal-total format was abandoned and replaced by a best-of-three series for the opening round and quarterfinals. In 1992, the entire tournament was switched to a single-elimination format and divided into two regional locations that would feed into the "Frozen Four". For the first time, in 1999, the championship was held in a region without a local Division I program when the championship round was awarded to Anaheim, California.

No. Season Tournament No. of teamsin tournament Start Finish NCAA champion(number) Championconference Championrecord Championship site 411987–88198812April 2 CCHA(33–7–6)Lake Placid, New York 421988–89198912April 1 ECAC(31–3–0)St. Paul, Minnesota 431989–901990 12 April 1 (5) WCHA(36–9–1)Detroit, Michigan 441990–91199112March 30 WCHA(38–5–4)St. Paul, Minnesota 451991–921992 12 April 4 (2) CCHA(30–9–4)Albany, New York 461992–93199312April 3 Hockey East(42–1–2)Milwaukee, Wisconsin 471993–94199412April 2 (3) CCHA(31–10–4)St. Paul, Minnesota 481994–95199512April 1 (4) Hockey East(31–6–3)Providence, Rhode Island 491995–96199612March 30 (8) CCHA(34–7–2)Cincinnati, Ohio 501996–97199712March 29 (6) WCHA(31–10–2)Milwaukee, Wisconsin 511997–981998 12 April 4 (9) CCHA(34–11–1)Boston, Massachusetts 521998–99199912October 3April 3 (2) Hockey East(31–6–4)Anaheim, California 531999–00200012October 1April 8 (7) WCHA(31–8–5)Providence, Rhode Island 542000–01200112October 6April 7 (2) Hockey East(33–8–2)Albany, New York 552001–02200212October 5April 6 (4) WCHA(32–8–4)St. Paul, Minnesota

Further expansion and commercialization After the addition of two more conferences around the turn of the century (MAAC and CHA, neither of which now sponsors men's hockey), bringing the total number to six, and with each receiving an at-large bid starting in 2001 and 2003 respectively, the tournament was again expanded by four teams. Two additional regional groups were added (Northeast and Midwest), and byes into the quarterfinals were eliminated. Additionally, the "Frozen Four" was seen as a vehicle to increase both revenue and the popularity of college hockey, and as such, the apex of the tournament began to move around to non-traditional college hockey areas, usually in the buildings of NHL teams.

The first decade of the 21st century saw significant changes to hockey's conference landscape. After the 2002–03 season, the MAAC hockey programs split from the league to form the Atlantic Hockey Association. CHA stopped sponsoring men's hockey after the 2009–10 season, but continued to operate as a women's league through the 2023–24 season.

No. Season Tournament No. of teamsin tournament Start Finish NCAA champion(number) Championconference Championrecord Championship site 562002–03200316October 4April 12 (5) WCHA(28–8–9)Buffalo, New York 572003–042004 16 October 3 April 10 (6) WCHA(27–12–5)Boston, Massachusetts 582004–05200516October 3April 9 (7) WCHA(32–9–2)Columbus, Ohio 592005–06200616October 7April 8 (6) WCHA(30–10–3)Milwaukee, Wisconsin 602006–07200716October 6April 7 (3) CCHA(26–13–3)St. Louis, Missouri 612007–08200816October 7April 12 (3) Hockey East(25–11–8)Denver, Colorado 622008–09200916October 10April 11 (5) Hockey East(35–6–4)Washington, D.C. 632009–10201016October 8April 10 (4) Hockey East(29–10–3)Detroit, Michigan 642010–112011 16 October 2April 9 WCHA(26–10–6)St. Paul, Minnesota 652011–12201216October 1April 7 (5) Hockey East(33–10–1)Tampa, Florida 662012–13201316October 6April 13 ECAC(22–12–3)Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Conference realignment, dissolution, and mergers In 2010, Terry Pegula, an alumnus of Pennsylvania State University, donated $102 million to his alma mater for the express purpose of building a brand-new hockey arena and funding the upgrade of both the men's and women's ice hockey programs from club level to Division I.

This began a chain of events that caused a massive amount of conference realignment, the founding of two new conferences, and the ending of one of the oldest conferences in the NCAA. Penn State's rise to the D-I ranks gave the Big Ten its sixth university that sponsored varsity men's ice hockey, a number significant for two reasons. First, Big Ten bylaws dictate that the conference can only sponsor a sport if it has at least six participating members. More significantly, NCAA rules on conference formation dictate that at least six teams must be present for a conference to receive an automatic bid into the NCAA tournament. In short order, the other five teams announced their intention to leave their conferences (WCHA and CCHA). In response, several members of the WCHA, including traditional powerhouses Denver and North Dakota, split to form a new conference, the NCHC. The NCHC quickly grew to eight member teams, leaving the WCHA with only four remaining schools and the CCHA with six. Five of the remaining CCHA schools then joined the WCHA, along with the Independent Alabama-Huntsville, bringing the WCHA up to 10 member schools. The remaining CCHA team, Notre Dame, joined Hockey East. In essence, all of the universities that changed conferences were not significantly harmed by the upheaval, because no team was left without a conference by the start of the 2013–14 season. However, the shift did create one more automatic qualifier for the tournament, reducing the chance to receive an at-large bid for all schools across the nation.

In November 2019, the seven Midwestern schools among the 10 members of the men's WCHA jointly announced they would leave the league after the 2020–21 season, citing the league's extended geographic footprint as a reason for this move. On February 18, 2020, these seven schools announced they would start play in a new CCHA in the 2021–22 season. In July of that year, the revived CCHA announced that St. Thomas, which had just received NCAA approval to move directly from Division III to Division I starting in July 2021, would join the league upon its arrival in D-I.

The 2020 tournament was canceled on March 12, 2020, just before the start of most conference postseason tournaments, due to concerns about the COVID-19 pandemic.

After the 2023–24 season, the Atlantic Hockey Association merged with the women's College Hockey America to form Atlantic Hockey America. The predecessor conferences had operated with a single commissioner and office staff since 2010.