The Youngstown State Penguins football team represents Youngstown State University in American college football. Youngstown State currently plays as a member of the NCAA at the NCAA Division I Football Championship Subdivision (formerly known as Division I-AA) and is a member of the Missouri Valley Football Conference (MVFC). The Penguins have played their home games in Stambaugh Stadium, more commonly called "The Ice Castle," since 1982.

YSU football has been one of the leading programs in the NCAA Division I Football Championship Subdivision, winning four national championships under former head coach Jim Tressel, which is third behind North Dakota State's eight titles and Georgia Southern's six. Overall, YSU has made fourteen playoff appearances since Division I FCS (then Division I-AA) was formed in 1978.

History

Conference affiliations 1938–72: Independent 1973–77: NCAA Division II Independent 1978–80: Mid-Continent Conference 1981–87: Ohio Valley Conference 1988–96 NCAA Division I-AA Independent 1997–present: Missouri Valley Football Conference (known as the Gateway Football Conference until June 2008)

Early history The YSU football program began in 1938 as an Independent NCAA team under head coach Dwight "Dike" Beede. The Penguins played their first game on September 15, 1938, in a 12–6 loss to Geneva College. About a month later, on October 22, 1938, Youngstown State won its first game with a 20–0 shutout at Westminster College (PA). The Penguins won their first home game on November 3, 1938, with a 20–14 win against Davis & Elkins College.

Longtime head coach, Dwight "Dike" Beede, made a historical impact on the game of American football after noticing on-field confusion due to officials using whistles to signal a penalty. Beede invented the penalty flag and it was used for the first time during a game on October 17, 1941, against Oklahoma City University at the Youngstown's Rayen Stadium. The flag is now standard at all football games.

Dwight Beede retired from the program after the 1972 season and was replaced by Rey Dempsey starting in the 1973 season. After 35 years as an independent program, the football team joined NCAA Division II in 1973. In the 1974 season, the Penguins qualified for the Division II playoffs after going 8–1 in the regular season. YSU fell 14–35 against Delaware in the program's first playoff game. Following the 1974 season, Dempsey left Youngstown State to become a special-teams coach for the Detroit Lions 1975, he was In the three seasons at YSU he compiled a 12–8 record.

Bill Narduzzi became the third coach in program history in 1975. The team joined the Mid-Continent Conference in 1978 and recorded a 9-win regular season under Narduzzi and claimed the Mid-Continent Conference Championship. Narduzzi led Youngstown State to its first playoff win on November 25, 1978 against Nebraska–Omaha. The 21–14 win advanced the team into the Division II Semifinal Playoff Game where the Penguins lost to Eastern Illinois 22–26. The team finished the season with a record of 10–2, the first 10-win season for the program. The 1979 season saw Youngstown State claim their second Mid-Continent Conference Champions going undefeated in conference games and losing only a single game to Delaware. The Penguins defeated South Dakota State 50–7 in the Division II Quarterfinal Playoff Game and shut out Alabama A&M 52–0 in the Division II Semifinal Playoff Game. The win in the semifinal round gave Youngstown State its first appearance in an NCAA Football Championship. The Penguins faced the Delaware Fightin' Blue Hens in the Zia Bowl in Albuquerque, New Mexico for the NCAA Division II Championship. In the championship, YSU was defeated by Delaware 21–38 and finished the season with a record of 11–2. In 1981, Youngstown State joined the Ohio Valley Conference (OVC). After going 2–8–1 in the 1980 season, playing a majority of Division I opponents, the Penguins finished their first season in Division I and the OVC with a record of 7–4, including an upset of Cincinnati who was playing as a Division I FBS Independent.

Recent history The program's most successful period came from 1986 to 2000 under Jim Tressel. Tressel led the Penguins to four NCAA Division I-AA National Championships. In 1991, YSU won its first national championship, defeating Marshall, and won two more national championships in the following three seasons: against Marshall in 1993 and Boise State in 1994. The Penguins won a fourth title in 1997 with a 10–9 victory against McNeese State. The Tressel era of YSU football also included two stints as national runner-up in 1992 and 1999. YSU's four national championships are third in Division I FCS only to North Dakota State's ten titles and Georgia Southern's six. Tressel was also named Division I-AA Coach of the Year in ’91, ’93, ’94 and ’97.

Tressel left Youngstown State following the 2000 season to coach Ohio State, where he coached from 2001 to 2010. Tressel resigned from Ohio State in 2011 after an NCAA investigation of rules violations during the 2010 season and Ohio State self-vacating their wins for the 2010 season. Tressel's first incident with the NCAA came during his tenure as YSU head coach when it emerged in 1994 that Ray Issac, the quarterback on the Penguins' 1991 national championship team, had received benefits from Mickey Monus, who was a major benefactor to Youngstown State University. Over Issac's college career, Monus gifted $10,000 in cash and the use of several cars. The NCAA inquired after being tipped off about Monus' actions but dropped it after a cursory internal investigation by Youngstown State. The true scope of the violations was only revealed in 1998 when Isaac admitted tampering with a juror in Monus' fraud trial. Youngstown State admitted to a lack of institutional control and docked itself some scholarships, but was allowed to keep its 1991 title since the statute of limitations had expired.

His successor, Jon Heacock, did not win a national championship, but still delivered consistent seasons and took them to a national semifinal appearance in 2006 (losing to eventual national champion Appalachian State) before resigning following the 2009 season. Eric Wolford, a Youngstown native who has been labeled a top recruiter at the NCAA Division I Football Bowl Subdivision level, was named the sixth head coach in school history on December 15, 2009. Wolford recorded a 3–8 record in his first season in 2010. Despite the record, Youngstown State led at some point in all but one game they played. The streak was ended in the first game of the 2011 season when YSU lost to Michigan State 6–28 and never held a lead in the game. The 2011 season featured improvement to a 6–5 record, highlighted by a victory over eventual FCS National Champion North Dakota State.

The Penguins beat Pittsburgh, 31–17, on September 1, 2012, at Heinz Field in Pittsburgh. This marked the first time the Penguins had ever beaten a Bowl Championship Series team, though they have several wins over FBS teams from non-automatic qualifier conferences, such as the MAC.

The 2016 Penguins went on to the NCAA FCS Championship, in which they lost to James Madison, 28–14. YSU would have not made it to the FCS National Championship game if it were not for one of the best catches in College Football History. In the FCS Semifinals, the Penguins visited Eastern Washington. The Penguins won by a score of 40 to 38. The Penguins prevailed thanks to a touchdown catch by Kevin Rader with one second on the clock. Rader caught the pass pinned to the defender's back from Quarterback Hunter Wells.

National championships Youngstown State has won four national championships. 1991Jim Tressel NCAA Division I-AA 12–3 25–17 Marshall1993 NCAA Division I-AA 13–2 17–5 Marshall1994 NCAA Division I-AA 14–0–1 28–14 Boise State1997 NCAA Division I-AA 13–2 10–9 McNeese State

Conference championships Youngstown State has won five conference championships, three outright and two shared. Note that the team was not a member of any conference before 1978 and from 1988 to 1996. 1978 Bill Narduzzi The Summit League 10–2 5–0 1979 11–2 5–0 1987† Jim Tressel Ohio Valley Conference 8–4 5–1 2005† Jon Heacock Gateway Football Conference 8–3 5–2 2006 11–3 6–1 † denotes co-champion

Postseason history NCAA Division II 1978 II Quarterfinal Youngstown State 21 Nebraska–Omaha 14 II Semifinal Eastern Illinois 26 Youngstown State 221979 II Quarterfinal Youngstown State 50 South Dakota State 7 II Semifinal Youngstown State 52 Alabama A&M 0 II Championship Game Delaware 38 Youngstown State 21

NCAA Division I-AA/FCS 1987 I-AA First Round Northern Iowa 31 Youngstown State 281989 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 28 Eastern Kentucky 24I-AA Quarterfinal Furman 42 Youngstown State 23 1990 I-AA First Round Central Florida 20 Youngstown State 171991 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 17 Villanova 16 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 30 Nevada 28 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 10 Samford 0 I-AA Championship Game Youngstown State 25 Marshall 171992 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 23 Villanova 20 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 42 The Citadel 17 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 19 Northern Iowa 7 I-AA Championship Game Marshall 31 Youngstown State 281993 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 56 Central Florida 30 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 34 Georgia Southern 14 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 35 Idaho 16 I-AA Championship Game Youngstown State 17 Marshall 51994 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 63 Alcorn State 20 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 18 Eastern Kentucky 15 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 28 Montana 9 I-AA Championship Game Youngstown State 28 Boise State 141997 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 28 Hampton 13 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 37 Villanova 34 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 25 Eastern Washington 14 I-AA Championship Game Youngstown State 10 McNeese State 91999 I-AA First Round Youngstown State 30 Montana 27 I-AA Quarterfinal Youngstown State 41 North Carolina A&T 3 I-AA Semifinal Youngstown State 27 Florida A&M 24 I-AA Championship Game Georgia Southern 59 Youngstown State 24 2000 I-AA First Round Richmond 10 Youngstown State 32006 FCS First Round Youngstown State 35 James Madison 31 FCS Quarterfinal Youngstown State 28 Illinois State 21 FCS Semifinal Appalachian State 49 Youngstown State 242016 FCS First Round Youngstown State 38 Samford 24 FCS Second Round Youngstown State 40 Jacksonville State 24 FCS Quarterfinal Youngstown State 30 Wofford 23 OT FCS Semifinal Youngstown State 40 Eastern Washington 38 FCS Championship Game James Madison 28 Youngstown State 14 2023 FCS First Round Youngstown State 40 Duquesne 7 FCS Second Round Villanova 45 Youngstown State 28 2025 FCS First Round Yale 43 Youngstown State 42

Home venue YSU plays its home games at Stambaugh Stadium, nicknamed "The Ice Castle", which has an official capacity of 20,630.

Rivalries

Akron

The Penguins have played the Zips 35 times in football. They played for the Steel Tire, named for the products that both cities were known for. The trophy comes from the main products of the two cities; Akron for its rubber and Youngstown for its steel. In 1995, the series was discontinued with Youngstown State holding a 19–14–2 edge. The two schools were scheduled to meet on September 5, 2020, but was canceled due to continuing concerns over the COVID-19 pandemic.

Other rivals Other rivals of the Penguins include conference members; Northern Iowa and North Dakota State along with Mid-American Conference (MAC) member Kent State.

Notable players