This is a list of the cast members of the science fiction/horror-themed children's television series, Are You Afraid of the Dark? The cast members are part of "The Midnight Society" during the series.

Are You Afraid of the Dark? (1992–1996) cast ActorCharacterSeasons12345 Ross Hull Gary colspan="5" Jason Alisharan Frank colspan="4" colspan="1" Rachel Blanchard Kristen colspan="2" colspan="3" Nathaniel Moreau David colspan="2" colspan="3" Raine Pare-Coull Betty Ann colspan="5" Jodie Resther Kiki colspan="5" Jacob Tierney Eric colspan="1" colspan="4" Daniel DeSanto Tucker colspan="2" colspan="3" Joanna García Samantha colspan="2" colspan="3" Codie Lucas Wilbee Stig colspan="4" colspan="1"

Are You Afraid of the Dark? (1999–2000) cast ActorCharacterSeasons67 Kareem Blackwell Quinn colspan="2" Elisha Cuthbert Megan colspan="2" Daniel DeSanto Tucker colspan="2" David Deveau Andy colspan="2" Vanessa Lengies Vange colspan="2" Ross Hull Gary colspan="1" colspan="1"

Are You Afraid of the Dark? (2019–2022) cast ActorCharacterSeasons123 Lyliana Wray Rachel Carpenter colspan="1" colspan="2" Miya Cech Akiko Yamato colspan="1" colspan="2" Sam Ashe Arnold Gavin Coscarelli colspan="1" colspan="2" Jeremy Ray Taylor Graham Raimi colspan="1" colspan="2" Tamara Smart Louise Fulci colspan="1" colspan="2" Bryce Gheisar Luke McCoy colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Malia Baker Gabby Lewis colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Beatrice Kitsos Hanna Romero colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Parker Queenan Connor Stevens colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Arjun Athalye Jai Malya colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Dominic Mariche Seth Romero colspan="1" colspan="1" colspan="1" Telci Huynh Kayla colspan="2" colspan="1" Conor Sherry Max colspan="2" colspan="1" Luca Padovan Leo colspan="2" colspan="1" Dior Goodjohn Summer colspan="2" colspan="1" Chance Hurstfield Ferris colspan="2" colspan="1"

Notes

The original pilot episode featured a different cast as the Midnight Society, with Ross Hull as David, Mark Bigney as Eric, Robin McKenna as Kristen, Bethanny Nurse as Kiki, Hasani Paris-Crooks as Frank, Marisa Rossy as Betty Ann, and Shane Smythe as Gary. When Are You Afraid of the Dark? was picked up as a series, the pilot was re-shot with the Midnight Society recast. Daniel DeSanto (Tucker) is the only actor to be a main cast member in both the 1992–1996 and the 1999–2000 incarnations of Are You Afraid of the Dark? Ross Hull (Gary), who starred throughout the entire 1992–1996 run of the incarnation of Are You Afraid of the Dark? guest-starred in the three-part "The Tale of Silver Sight" episode of the 1999–2000 incarnation of the show.

References