The Technical Group of Independent Members was a heterogeneous political technical group with seats in the European Parliament between 1999 and 2001. Unlike other political groups of the European Parliament, it did not have a coherent political complexion. Its existence prompted a five-year examination of whether mixed Groups were compatible with the Parliament. After multiple appeals to the European Court of First Instance (now known as the General Court) and the European Court of Justice, the question was finally answered: overtly mixed Groups would not be allowed.
History
Creation of TGI MEPs in the European Parliament form themselves into Groups along ideological, not national, lines. Each Group is assumed to have a common set of political principles, (known as a common "affinity", or "complexion"), and each Group thus formed is granted benefits. This puts MEPs who cannot form themselves into Groups at a disadvantage. In the Parliament's past, they got around this by forming Groups with only tenuous common ground, and Parliament turned a blind eye. But the crunch point arrived on 20 July 1999, when a Group called TGI ( in French, from ) was formed. The Group consisted of the spectacularly unlikely partnership of the far-right French Front National, the regionalist-separatist Lega Nord of Italy, and liberal Italian Bonino List. Further, the 19 July letter ("constituent declaration") setting up the Group emphasised the political independence of the Group members from each other:
At the plenary sitting of 20 July 1999 the President of Parliament announced that the TGI Group had been set up.
Objections to its creation Believing that the conditions laid down by the Rules of Procedure of the European Parliament for establishing Groups had not been met, the leaders of the other Groups called for the Committee on Constitutional Affairs to give an interpretation. The Committee on Constitutional Affairs ruled that the constituent declaration broke Rule 29(1), stating that:
First dissolution Parliament was notified on 13 September 1999 of the ruling. TGI members made two proposals to amend the Rules of Procedure and allow mixed Groups to be formed, (one of which was signed by 68 other members), but the next day Parliament adopted (412 to 56 with 36 abstentions) the Committee on Constitutional Affairs's interpretation of Rule 29, forcibly dissolving the Group ("the act of 14 September 1999"), and making 13 September 1999 the last day of the Group's existence.
Appeals to the Court of First Instance On 5 October 1999, Jean-Claude Martinez MEP and Charles de Gaulle MEP lodged two appeals with the Court of First Instance. The first one (Case T-222/99R) was based on Article 242 of the EC Treaty and was intended to suspend the enforcement of the act of 14 September 1999. The second one (Case T-222/99) was based on Article 230 of the EC Treaty and was intended to annul the act of 14 September 1999.
The first appeal (Case T-222/99R) was upheld, and the act of 14 September 1999 was suspended by the Court of First Instance on 25 November 1999.
Resurrection The Group was temporarily resurrected on December 1, 1999 until the Court came to a decision on the second appeal. The Budget for the year was somewhat advanced, but the Committee on Budgets managed to come up with the money to give TGI the secretarial allowances and 14 temporary posts that a Group of its size was entitled to.
Court of First Instance rejects the appeals Meanwhile the second appeal (Case T-222/99) had been joined by two others, one (Case T-327/99) from the Front National as a corporate entity, the other (T-329/99) from the Bonino List as a corporate entity and from Emma Bonino, Marco Pannella, Marco Cappato, Gianfranco Dell’Alba, Benedetto Della Vedova, Olivier Dupuis and Maurizio Turco as individuals.
On 2 October 2001, the Court of First Instance delivered its verdict (2002/C 17/20). It found that Article 230 of the EC Treaty did not contradict the act of 14 September 1999. It joined together the three appeals, dismissed them, and ordered the applicants to pay costs.
Second dissolution President Fontaine announced that the Court of First Instance had declared against the appeal and that the disbandment was back in effect from October 2, 2001, the date of the declaration. TGI appeared on the list of Political Groups in the European Parliament for the last time on October 4, 2001.
Appeals to the European Court of Justice On 11 October 2001, Gianfranco Dell'Alba on behalf of TGI announced that they would appeal the Court of First Instance's decision to the European Court of Justice. In the event, two appeals were lodged with the ECJ: one (Case C-486/01 P) from the Front National as a corporate entity on 17 December 2001, the other (Case C-488/01 P) from Jean-Claude Martinez as an individual on 11 December 2001.
European Court of Justice rejects the appeals The Martinez appeal was thrown out (2004/C 59/03) and the applicant ordered to pay costs on November 11, 2003. The Front National appeal dragged out for another six months, but in the end it was also thrown out (2004/C 217/01) and the applicant ordered to pay costs on 29 June 2004.
Final result After five years and several appeals to the Court of First Instance and the Court of Justice, the principle was settled: mixed Groups would not be allowed to exist.
Consequences Whilst the Parliament and Courts concerned themselves with the existence of TGI, the Committee on Constitutional Affairs examined the implications of mixed Groups and the wider issue of political Groups per se.
Rationale for Groups During their deliberations in December 1999, the Committee on Constitutional Affairs laid down the rationale for the existence of Groups:
Changes to the Rules of Procedure In August 2003, the Committee recommended changes to the Rules of Procedure which would establish the benefits and funding to be provided to the Groups, and similarly those for the Non-Inscrits (the ungrouped members). These changes were later implemented.
Situation in February 2008 As of February 2008, the Parliament's Rules of Procedure formulate the requirement for Groups to have a common political affinity (Rule 29), define Groups as bodies that are part of the European Union (Rule 30), establish benefits available to the Groups (Rule 30) and Non-Inscrits (Rule 31), and who decides what positions each Group gets (Rule 32).
The requirement for a common affinity is on a "don't ask, don't tell" basis: the Groups are assumed to have one by virtue of their existence and provided they do not obviously act in a manner contrary to that assumption, the Parliament will not enquire too closely. If the Group members do deny their common affinity, then the Group may be challenged and dissolved. The exact wording of Rule 29, part 1 is:
These requirements had implications for the formulation of the far-right Group called "Identity, Tradition, Sovereignty" in 2007.
Member Parties at 23 July 1999 The Group was founded on July 20 with 29 members, but nine members (Angelilli, Berlato, Fini, Musumeci, Muscardini, Nobilia, Poli Bortone, Segni and Turchi) left on July 21 and two members (Atxalandabaso and Formentini) left on July 22, leaving a membership of 18 by July 23. Member state MEPs Party MEPs Notes5Front National5Bruno Gollnisch, Carl Lang, Charles De Gaulle, Jean-Claude Martinez, Jean-Marie Le Pen2Vlaams Blok2Frank Vanhecke, Karel C.C. Dillen11Bonino List7Benedetto Della Vedova, Emma Bonino, Gianfranco Dell'alba, Marco Cappato, Marco Pannella, Maurizio Turco, Olivier DupuisLega Nord3Francesco Enrico Speroni, Umberto Bossi, Gian Paolo GobboTricolour Flame1Roberto Felice Bigliardo
Sources Department of Economics, University of California, BerkeleyDemocracy in the European Parliament Konrad-Adenauer-StiftungPolitical Groups of the European Parliament European ParliamentThe Week : 20-07-99(s)Reinstatement of Independents' GroupTechnical group disbandedDaily Notebook 04-10-2001Political Groups Annual Accounts 2001-2006"Working Document on the proposed amendments, tabled pursuant to Rule 181 of the Rules of Procedure, to Rule 30 and on a horizontal amendment to the Rules of Procedure (B5-0059/99 and B5-0060/99)", from the Committee on Constitutional AffairsFormation of Technical Group of Independent Members rejectedEuropean Parliament Debates, Wednesday, 1 December 1999 - BrusselsDocument PE 282.354 "Minutes of the sitting of 1 and 2 December 1999"Minutes of the sitting of 1 and 2 December 1999Document PE 232.208 "Draft Report on the supplementary estimates to Parliament's budget estimates for 2000", from the Committee on BudgetsCourt rules on TGIDocument PV 33 PE 309.499 "Minutes of the sitting of Wednesday 3 October 2001"European Parliament Debates, Wednesday, 3 October 2001 - StrasbourgDocument 10/A-2001 "Activities" from the Directorate For The Planning Of Parliamentary BusinessDebates Wednesday, 3 October 2001 - StrasbourgDocument PE 323.592 A5-0283/2003 "Report On Insertion Of A New Rule 29a In Parliament's Rules Of Procedure: Activities And Legal Situation Of The Political Groups", from the Committee on Constitutional Affairs, 28 August 2003Rules of Procedure of the European Parliament, 16th edition, February 2008European Parliament Minutes (Proceedings of the Sitting) Final Edition - 21 July 1999European Parliament Minutes (Proceedings of the Sitting) Final Edition - 22 July 1999 EUR-LexJudgment of the Court of First Instance of 2 October 2001, (2002/C 17/20)6.4.2002 C 84/47 Official Journal of the European Communities(2004/C 59/03) of the European Court of Justice in Case C-488/01 PNotice 2004/C 217/01, Judgment of the Court (Grand Chamber) of 29 June 2004 in Case C-486/01 P: Front National v European ParliamentJudgement (2004/C 217/01) of the European Court of Justice in Case C-486/01 P International Political Science Review"Eastward Enlargement by the European Union and Transnational Parties", International Political Science Review, Giorgia Delsoldato 2002; vol 23; pp 269 The Court of Justice of the European Communitiesof the Court of First Instance in 2001"Proceedings Of The Court Of Justice And The Court Of First Instance Of The European Communities", week of 10 to 14 November 2003, number 30/03 European Parliament archive of MEPsEuropean Parliament profile of Francesco SperoniEuropean Parliament profile of Gianfranco Dell'albaEuropean Parliament profile of Bruno GollnischEuropean Parliament profile of Carl LangEuropean Parliament profile of Charles De GaulleEuropean Parliament profile of Jean-Claude MartinezEuropean Parliament profile of Jean-Marie Le PenEuropean Parliament profile of Frank VanheckeEuropean Parliament profile of Karel C.C. DillenEuropean Parliament profile of Benedetto Della VedovaEuropean Parliament profile of Emma BoninoEuropean Parliament profile of Marco CappatoEuropean Parliament profile of Marco PannellaEuropean Parliament profile of Maurizio TurcoEuropean Parliament profile of Olivier DupuisEuropean Parliament profile of Umberto BossiEuropean Parliament profile of Gian Paolo GobboEuropean Parliament profile of Roberto Felice Bigliardo
References