Counted amongst the honours achieved by the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles since their first season in 1947 are eight 8 NRL Premierships and one World Club Challenge. The club's players and coaches have also received several individual awards.
Media and Association Awards {| class="wikitable" width="75%" style="font-size:90%" |- ! colspan=11 |Manly Warringah Sea Eagles |- |Rugby League Immortal Bob Fulton (1981 – Original Inductee) |- |Team of the Century Ken Irvine (Wing), Bob Fulton (Reserve) |- |ARL/NRL Hall of Fame Ken Arthurson (Contributor), Kerry Boustead, Les Boyd, Roy Bull, Graham Eadie, Bob Fulton, Ken Irvine, Eddie Lumsden, Cliff Lyons, Steve Menzies, John O'Neill |- |NSWRL Hall of Fame Bob Fulton, Ken Irvine |- |NSWRL Team of the Century Ken Irvine (Wing), Bob Fulton (Five-Eight), Roy Bull (Reserve) |- |Country (CRL) Team of the Century Eddie Lumsden (Wing), Bob Fulton (Five-Eight) |- |Illawarra Rugby League Team of the Century Bob Fulton (Five-Eight), Kevin Schubert (Hooker), John Dorahy (Reserve) |- |Newcastle Rugby League Team of the Century Eddie Lumsden (Wing) |- |Top 100 Players (Australia) Kerry Boustead, Roy Bull, Graham Eadie, Bob Fulton, Ken Irvine, John O'Neill |- |Indigenous Rugby League Team of the Century Dale Shearer (Wing), Cliff Lyons (Lock), Mal Cochrane (Hooker) |- |NSWRL State of Origin Greats Noel Cleal (2nd Row), Michael O'Connor (Wing), Ian Roberts (Prop), Geoff Toovey (Halfback) |- |Queensland State of Origin All-Time Team Paul Vautin (Reserve) |- |British Rugby League Hall of Fame Mal Reilly |- |New Zealand Rugby League Legends Of League Mark Broadhurst |- |Rothmans Medal Graham Eadie (1974), Mal Cochrane (1986) |- |Dally M Awards |- |Player of the Year Cliff Lyons (1990, 1994), Matt Orford (2008), Tom Trbojevic (2021) |- |Silver Dally M Ian Roberts (1993), Cliff Lyons (1995) |- |Best Fullback Graham Eadie (1983), Matthew Ridge (1995), Tom Trbojevic (2021) |- |Best Winger John Ribot (1982), Kerry Boustead (1983), Reuben Garrick (2021) |- |Best Centre Michael O'Connor (1987, 1988), Jamie Lyon (2010, 2011, 2013, 2014) |- |Best Five-Eight Cliff Lyons (1990, 1994) |- |Best Halfback Matt Orford (2008), Daly Cherry-Evans (2014) |- |Best Lock Forward Des Hasler (1991), Steve Menzies (2002), Ben Kennedy (2005, 2006) |- |Best Second Rower Paul Vautin (1983), Noel Cleal (1984, 1986), Steve Menzies (1994, 1995, 1998), Anthony Watmough (2007, 2009), Glenn Stewart (2008) |- |Best Hooker Mal Cochrane (1986, 1987), Jim Serdaris (1996), Geoff Toovey (1999) |- |Best Prop Forward Dave Brown (1983), Martin Bella (1990), Ian Roberts (1993, 1994) |- |Top Try-Scorer Bob Fulton (1972, 1973, 1976), Kevin Junee (1974), Russel Gartner (1977), Tom Mooney (1979), Phil Blake (1983, 1986), Steve Menzies (1995), Terry Hill (1997 - ARL), Brett Stewart (2008), David Williams (2013) |- |Top Points Scorer Ron Rowles (1951, 1952, 1953, 1954), Graham Eadie (1974, 1975, 1976), Matthew Ridge (1995), Reuben Garrick (2021) |- |Rookie of the Year Phil Blake (1982), Jack Elsegood (1993), Steve Menzies (1994), Daly Cherry-Evans (2011) |- |Captain of the Year Ben Kennedy (2006), Jason King (2012), Jamie Lyon (2012, 2014) |- |Coach of the Year Bob Fulton (1983) |- |Dave Brown Medal* Dennis Ward (1972), Bob Fulton (1973), Graham Eadie (1976, 1978) |- |Clive Churchill Medal Cliff Lyons (1987), Geoff Toovey (1996), Brent Kite (2008), Glenn Stewart (2011), Daly Cherry-Evans (2013) |- |Rugby League Week Player of the Year John Mayes (1973), Bob Fulton (1975), Phil Sigsworth (1983), Cliff Lyons (1994) |- |Norwich Rising Star – Rookie of the Year Jack Elsegood (1993), John Hopoate (1995) |- |Rugby League Players Association |- |Players’ Player Ben Kennedy (2006), Tom Trbojevic (2021) |- |Best Country Player Brent Kite (2006) |- |Rookie Of The Year David Williams (2008) |- |Clubman Of The Year Jason King (2008) |- |New Zealand Player of the Year Darrell Williams (1989), Kieran Foran (2013) |- |NSW Player of the Year Roy Bull (1954), Bob Fulton (1972, 1973) |- |Sun Herald Best and Fairest Rex Mossop (1958), Dennis Ward (1968) |- |Ken Stephen Memorial Award Ian Roberts (1994), Michael Monaghan (2006) |} * No longer awarded. Replaced by the Clive Churchill Medal in 1986
Club honours {| class="wikitable" width="85%" style="font-size:90%" |- ! colspan=11 |Manly Warringah Sea Eagles |- |Clubman of the Year Owen Cunningham (1994), Cliff Lyons (1995), Des Hasler (1996), Geoff Toovey (1997), Craig Hancock (1998), Steve Menzies (1999, 2002), Chad Randall (2003), Albert Torrens (2004), Luke Williamson (2005), Chris Hicks (2006), Michael Monaghan (2007), Mark Bryant (2008), George Rose (2010), Michael Robertson (2011) Joe Galuvao (2012), Brett Stewart (2013), Brenton Lawrence (2014, 2016), Josh Starling (2015), Jake Trbojevic (2017), Joel Thompson (2018), Glenn Moore (2019), Lachlan Croker (2024) |- |Best and Fairest Steve Menzies (2002), Chris Hicks (2004), Ben Kennedy (2005, 2006), Glenn Stewart (2007, 2008, 2011), Jason King (2009, 2010), Matt Ballin (2012), Anthony Watmough (2013), Brenton Lawrence (2014), Jake Trbojevic (2015, 2018, 2019), Tom Trbojevic (2016, 2021, 2024), Daly Cherry-Evans (2017, 2020, 2023), Lachlan Croker (2022) |- |Players’ Player John Hopoate (2002), Ben Kennedy (2005), Brent Kite (2006), Brett Stewart (2007, 2015), Brent Kite (2008), George Rose (2009) Jamie Lyon (2010, 2012), Steve Matai (2011), Daly Cherry-Evans (2013), Kieran Foran (2014), Jake Trbojevic (2016, 2017), Joel Thompson (2018, 2019), Tom Trbojevic (2024) |- |Rookie of the Year Jason King (2002), Steve Matai (2005), Travis Burns (2006), Michael Bani (2007), David Williams (2008), Kieran Foran (2009), Trent Hodkinson (2010), Daly Cherry-Evans (2011), Jorge Taufua (2012), Peta Hiku (2013), Jesse Sene-Lefao (2014), Tom Trbojevic (2015), Addin Fonua-Blake (2016), Brian Kelly (2017), Reuben Garrick (2019), Lehi Hopoate (2024) |- |Members Best and Fairest Ben Kennedy (2005, 2006), Brett Stewart (2007, 2014, 2015), Anthony Watmough (2007, 2009), Matt Orford (2008), Jamie Lyon (2010, 2012), Kieran Foran (2011), Daly Cherry-Evans (2013, 2018, 2024), Jake Trbojevic (2016, 2017, 2019)
Representative Players Below are the players to play representative football whilst in Manly colours. Notable Internationals to play for Manly, but not represent from the club, include New Zealand players Jock Butterfield, Trevor Kilkelly, Adrian Shelford and Tasesa Lavea, and Great Britain players Mal Reilly, Phil Lowe, Steve Norton, Andy Goodway, Kevin Ward and Welsh dual rugby international John Devereux.
{| class="wikitable" width="80%" style="font-size:90%" |- ! colspan=11 |Manly Warringah Sea Eagles |- |Australian Test Players 68 – Martin Bella, Johnny Bliss, Kerry Boustead, Les Boyd, Bill Bradstreet, Dave Brown, Ray Brown, Roy Bull, Peter Burke, Mark Carroll, Daly Cherry-Evans, Noel Cleal, Chris Close, Phil Daley, Bill Delamare, Graham Eadie, Bob Fulton, Daniel Gartner, Russel Gartner, Geoff Gerard, Johnny Gibbs, David Gillespie, Bill Hamilton, Les Hanigan, Des Hasler, Terry Hill, John Hopoate, Fred Jones, Ben Kennedy, Brent Kite, Nik Kosef, Max Krilich, Jack Lumsden, Jamie Lyon, Cliff Lyons, John McDonald, Paul McCabe, Steve Martin, Steve Menzies, Danny Moore, John Morgan, Rex Mossop, Wally O'Connell, Michael O'Connor, John O'Neill, Josh Perry, Terry Randall, John Ribot, Ray Ritchie, Ian Roberts, Kevin Schubert, Dale Shearer, Jack Sinclair, Frank Stanton, Brett Stewart, Glenn Stewart, Alan Thompson, Ian Thomson, Geoff Toovey, Jake Trbojevic, Tom Trbojevic, Paul Vautin, Mick Veivers, Bruce Walker, Dennis Ward, Anthony Watmough, David Williams, Tony Williams and Gordon Willoughby. |- |Australian Captains 2 – Max Krilich (1982–83) and Geoff Toovey (1996) |- |New Zealand Test Players 14 – Mark Broadhurst, Lewis Brown, Addin Fonua-Blake, Kieran Foran, Peta Hiku, Kevin Iro, Tony Iro, Steve Matai, Gene Ngamu, Matthew Ridge, Martin Taupau, Jared Waerea-Hargreaves, Dean Whare and Darrell Williams. |- |New Zealand Captains 2 – Matthew Ridge (1995) and Kieran Foran (2013) |- |Other Nations Test Players 31 – Josh Aloiai (Samoa), Nick Bradley-Qalilawa (Fiji), Gordon Chan Kum Tong (Samoa), Manase Fainu (Tonga), Addin Fonua-Blake (Tonga), Pita Godinet (Samoa), Solomon Haumono (Tonga), John Hopoate (Tonga), Lehi Hopoate (Tonga), Craig Innes (Rest of the World), Brent Kite (Tonga), Apisai Koroisau (Fiji), Toluta'u Koula (Tonga), Mark Lennon (Wales), Dunamis Lui (Samoa), Feleti Mateo (Tonga), Vic Mauro (Italy), Caleb Navale (Fiji), Haumole Olakau'atu (Tonga), Taniela Paseka (Tonga), Michael Robertson (Scotland), Josh Schuster (Samoa), Jesse Sene-Lefao (Samoa), Martin Taupau (Samoa), Jorge Taufua (Tonga / Samoa), Jazz Tevaga (Samoa), Christian Tuipulotu (Tonga), Akuila Uate (Fiji), Siosaia Vave (Tonga), Brayden Wiliame (Fiji), Matthew Wright (Samoa). |- |Tongan Captains 1 – Brent Kite (2013) |- |State Of Origin (NSW) 38 – Les Boyd, Ray Brown, Jamie Buhrer, Mark Carroll, Noel Cleal, Phil Daley, Graham Eadie, Geoff Gerard, David Gillespie, Craig Hancock, Des Hasler, Terry Hill, John Hopoate, William Hopoate, Ben Kennedy, Jason King, Brent Kite, Nik Kosef, Max Krilich, Jamie Lyon, Cliff Lyons, Steve Martin, Steve Menzies, Michael O'Connor, Haumole Olakau'atu, Ian Roberts, Jim Serdaris, Phil Sigsworth, Brett Stewart, Glenn Stewart, Alan Thompson, Geoff Toovey, Jake Trbojevic, Tom Trbojevic, Dylan Walker, Anthony Watmough, David Williams and Tony Williams. |- |NSW State of Origin Captains 3 – Max Krilich (1982–83), Geoff Toovey (1997) and Jake Trbojevic (2024) |- |State Of Origin (QLD) 16 – Matt Ballin, Steven Bell, Martin Bella, Kerry Boustead, Dave Brown, Daly Cherry-Evans, Chris Close, Owen Cunningham, Paul McCabe, Danny Moore, Nate Myles, John Ribot, Dale Shearer, Neil Tierney, Paul Vautin and Bruce Walker. |- |Qld State of Origin Captains 2 – Paul Vautin (1988, 1990), Daly Cherry-Evans (2019–2025) |- |State Of Residence (NSW) 35 – Johnny Bliss, Les Boyd, Bill Bradstreet, Ray Branighan, John Bucknall, Peter Burke, Roy Bull, Gary Collins, Bill Delamare, Lindsay Drake, Graham Eadie, Bob Fulton, Russel Gartner, Johnny Gibbs, Bill Hamilton, Les Hanigan, George Hunter, Fred Jones, Steve Martin, John McDonald, John Morgan, Rex Mossop, Wally O'Connell, Terry Randall, Ray Ritchie, Kevin Schubert, Jack Sinclair, Frank Stanton, Alec Tennant, Allan Thomson, Ian Thomson, Mick Veivers, Dennis Ward, Gordon Willoughby, Ron Willey |- |Prime Minister's XIII 21 – Brett Stewart (2006), Matt Orford (2006), Michael Robertson (2009), David Williams (2009), Glenn Stewart (2009), George Rose (2009), Tony Williams (2010), Chris Bailey (2010), Brenton Lawrence (2014), Jake Trbojevic (2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, 2023), Tom Symonds (2015), Tom Trbojevic (2017), Api Koroisau (2017), Dylan Walker (2017), Brian Kelly (2018), Daly Cherry-Evans (2018, 2022, 2023), Brad Parker (2019), Reuben Garrick (2019, 2024), Luke Brooks (2024), Ethan Bullemor (2024), Jason Saab (2025)
Below are Manly players that have represented Australia at the schoolboys level. Players in bold went on to make their first grade debut for Manly Warringah. Players in Italics currently playing for Manly Warringah Players with a * still playing NRL or Super League but no longer with Manly Warringah Updated 19 October 2024 {| class="wikitable" width="80%" style="font-size:90%" |- ! colspan=11 |Manly Warringah Sea Eagles |-