The All-Star Teams for the British Elite Ice Hockey League are voted for by members of Ice Hockey Journalists UK (formerly known as The British Ice Hockey Writers Association), and coaches and general managers of EIHL teams, to honour the best players at the end of each season.
2003–2004
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Curtis Cruickshank Basingstoke Bison Defence Dion Darling Sheffield Steelers Defence Kevin Bolibruck Sheffield Steelers Forward Jason Ruff Belfast Giants Forward John Craighead Nottingham Panthers Forward Mark Dutiaume Sheffield Steelers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Jayme Platt Manchester Phoenix Defence Jeff Burgoyne Cardiff Devils Defence Steve O'Brien Coventry Blaze Forward Steve Gallace Coventry Blaze Forward Mark Cadotte Nottingham Panthers Forward Erik Anderson Sheffield Steelers
2004–2005
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Jody Lehman Coventry Blaze Defence Neal Martin Coventry Blaze Defence Doug Schueller Coventry Blaze Forward Tony Hand Belfast Giants Forward Adam Calder Coventry Blaze Forward Vezio Sacratini Cardiff Devils
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Martin Klempa Belfast Giants Defence Wade Belak Coventry Blaze Defence Calle Carlsson Nottingham Panthers Forward Jon Cullen Cardiff Devils Forward George Awada Belfast Giants Forward Ashley Tait Coventry Blaze
2005–2006
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Trevor Koenig Newcastle Vipers Defence Neal Martin Coventry Blaze Defence Jan Krajíček Newcastle Vipers Forward Theoren Fleury Belfast Giants Forward Ed Courtenay Belfast Giants Forward Evan Cheverie Coventry Blaze
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Mike Minard Belfast Giants Defence Todd Kelman Belfast Giants Defence Jonathan Weaver Newcastle Vipers Forward Mark Dutiaume Sheffield Steelers Forward Tony Hand Edinburgh Capitals Forward George Awada Belfast Giants
2006–2007
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Trevor Koenig Coventry Blaze Defence Neal Martin Coventry Blaze Defence Jan Krajicek Nottingham Panthers Forward Mark Smith Cardiff Devils Forward Adam Calder Coventry Blaze Forward Dan Tessier Sheffield Steelers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ratislav Rovnianek Nottingham Panthers Defence Tyson Teplitsky Cardiff Devils Defence Jonathan Weaver Newcastle Vipers Forward Dan Carlson Coventry Blaze Forward Johan Molin Manchester Phoenix Forward Sean McAslan Nottingham Panthers
2007–2008
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Trevor Koenig Coventry Blaze Defence Jonathan Weaver Coventry Blaze Defence Neal Martin Coventry Blaze Forward Adam Calder Coventry Blaze Forward Joe Tallari Manchester Phoenix Forward Sean McAslan Nottingham Panthers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Tom Askey Nottingham Panthers Defence Rod Sarich Sheffield Steelers Defence Corey Neilson Nottingham Panthers Forward Peter Campbell Basingstoke Bison/Belfast Giants Forward Dan Carlson Coventry Blaze Forward Ed Courtenay Belfast Giants
2008–2009
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Jody Lehman Sheffield Steelers Defence Rod Sarich Sheffield Steelers Defence Steve Munn Sheffield Steelers Forward Paul Deniset Belfast Giants Forward David Beauregard Manchester Phoenix Forward Mark Hurtubise Edinburgh Capitals
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Andrew Verner Newcastle Vipers Defence Jonathan Weaver Coventry Blaze Defence Corey Neilson Nottingham Panthers Forward Greg Chambers Basingstoke Bison Forward Adam Calder Coventry Blaze Forward Tony Hand Manchester Phoenix 2009–2010
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Stephen Murphy Belfast Giants Defence Wes Jarvis Cardiff Devils Defence Jonathan Weaver Coventry Blaze Forward Colin Shields Belfast Giants Forward Luke Fulghum Coventry Blaze Forward Jade Galbraith Nottingham Panthers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Peter Hirsch Coventry Blaze Defence Michael Jacobsen Belfast Giants Defence Corey Neilson Nottingham Panthers Forward Greg Chambers Coventry Blaze Forward Owen Fussey Edinburgh Capitals Forward Jeffrey Szwez Belfast Giants 2010–2011
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ervins Mustukovs Sheffield Steelers Defence Jon Gleed Belfast Giants Forward Scott Matzka Cardiff Devils Forward Jereme Tendler Hull Stingrays Forward Jon Pelle Cardiff Devils Forward Craig Weller Cardiff Devils
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Stephen Murphy Belfast Giants Defence Jon Landry Braehead Clan Defence Corey Neilson Nottingham Panthers Forward Jeff Legue Sheffield Steelers Forward Luke Fulghum Coventry Blaze Forward Joe Talbot Sheffield Steelers 2011–2012
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Stephen Murphy Belfast Giants Defence Jeff Mason Belfast Giants Defence Corey Neilson Nottingham Panthers Forward Jade Galbraith Braehead Clan Forward Shea Guthrie Coventry Blaze Forward Robert Dowd Belfast Giants
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Craig Kowalski Nottingham Panthers Defence Jeremy Rebek Belfast Giants Defence Dustin Wood Coventry Blaze Forward Jeff Legue Sheffield Steelers Forward Jordan Fox Nottingham Panthers Forward David Beauregard Nottingham Panthers 2012–2013
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Craig Kowalski Nottingham Panthers Defence Robby Sandrock Belfast Giants Defence Michael Schutte Coventry Blaze Forward Mac Faulkner Cardiff Devils Forward Jereme Tendler Hull Stingrays Forward David Ling Nottingham Panthers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Nicola Riopel Dundee Stars Defence Derek Keller Fife Flyers Defence Eric Werner Nottingham Panthers Forward Bruce Graham Nottingham Panthers Forward Sami Ryhanen Dundee Stars Forward Ashley Goldie Braehead Clan 2013–2014
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Dan Bakala Dundee Stars Defence Calvin Elfring Belfast Giants Defence Robby Sandrock Belfast Giants Forward Ryan Ginand Coventry Blaze Forward Guillaume Doucet Hull Stingrays Forward Kevin Saurette Belfast Giants
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Stephen Murphy Belfast Giants Defence Tyson Marsh Cardiff Devils Defence Rory Rawlyk Dundee Stars Forward Nico Sacchetti Dundee Stars Forward Mac Faulkner Cardiff Devils Forward Jeffrey Szwez Belfast Giants 2014–2015
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Brian Stewart Coventry Blaze Defence Andrew Hotham Cardiff Devils Defence Ben O'Connor Sheffield Steelers Forward Joey Martin Cardiff Devils Forward Michael Forney Sheffield Steelers Forward Mathieu Roy Sheffield Steelers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Kyle Jones Braehead Clan Defence Scott Aarssen Braehead Clan Defence Tyson Marsh Cardiff Devils Forward Stefan Meyer Braehead Clan Forward Leigh Salters Braehead Clan Forward Brent Walton Cardiff Devils 2015–2016
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ben Bowns Cardiff Devils Defence Andrew Hotham Cardiff Devils Defence Ben O'Connor Sheffield Steelers Forward Joey Martin Cardiff Devils Forward Tyler Mosienko Sheffield Steelers Forward Juraj Kolnik Nottingham Panthers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Brian Stewart Coventry Blaze Defence Paul Phillips Manchester Storm Defence Derrick Walser Belfast Giants Forward James Desmarais Belfast Giants Forward Mathew Sisca Manchester Storm Forward Mathieu Roy Sheffield Steelers 2016–2017
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ben Bowns Cardiff Devils Defence Andrew Hotham Cardiff Devils Defence Jim Vandermeer Belfast Giants Forward Joey Martin Cardiff Devils Forward Mathieu Roy Sheffield Steelers Forward Vinny Scarsella Dundee Stars
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Shane Owen Fife Flyers Defence Felix-Antoine Poulin Dundee Stars Defence Derrick Walser Belfast Giants Forward Scott Pitt Braehead Clan Forward Matt Beca Braehead Clan Forward Blair Riley Belfast Giants 2017–2018
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ben Bowns Cardiff Devils Defence Jesse Craige Guildford Flames Defence Andrew Hotham Cardiff Devils Forward Mike Hammond Manchester Storm Forward Joey Martin Cardiff Devils Forward Sebastien Sylvestre Belfast Giants
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ervins Mustukovs Sheffield Steelers Defence Calle Ackered Guildford Flames Defence Mark Matheson Sheffield Steelers Forward John Dunbar Guildford Flames Forward Luke Moffatt Manchester Storm Forward Marc-Olivier Vallerand Coventry Blaze 2018–2019
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Tyler Beskorowany Belfast Giants Defence Gleason Fournier Cardiff Devils Defence Josh Roach Belfast Giants Forward Joey Martin Cardiff Devils Forward Darcy Murphy Belfast Giants Forward Ben Lake Coventry Blaze
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Ben Bowns Cardiff Devils Defence Calle Ackered Guildford Flames Defence Jesse Craige Guildford Flames Forward Charles Linglet Cardiff Devils Forward Kyle Baun Belfast Giants Forward Patrick Dwyer Belfast Giants 2019–2020
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender C.J. Motte Coventry Blaze Defence Gleason Fournier Cardiff Devils Defence Mark Matheson Nottingham Panthers Forward Joey Haddad Cardiff Devils Forward Sam Herr Nottingham Panthers Forward Luke Ferrara Coventry Blaze
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Matt Ginn Manchester Storm Defence Drydn Dow Dundee Stars Defence Marek Troncinsky Sheffield Steelers Forward Brendan Connolly Sheffield Steelers Forward Janne Laakkonen Coventry Blaze Forward Marc-Olivier Vallerand Sheffield Steelers 2021–2022
First Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Tyler Beskorowany Belfast Giants Defence Griffin Reinhart Belfast Giants Defence Jamal Watson Guildford Flames Forward Scott Conway Belfast Giants Forward J.J. Piccinich Belfast Giants Forward Marc-Olivier Vallerand Sheffield Steelers
Second Team Position Player Nationality Team Goaltender Mac Carruth Cardiff Devils Defence Matthew Register Cardiff Devils Defence Daine Todd Sheffield Steelers Forward Charlie Combs Dundee Stars Forward Mathieu Roy Glasgow Clan Forward Brodie Reid Cardiff Devils
2022–2023
First Team PositionPlayerNationalityTeamGoaltenderTyler BeskorowanyBelfast GiantsDefenceMarcus CrawfordCardiff DevilsDefenceGabe BastBelfast GiantsForwardScott ConwayBelfast GiantsForwardDaniel TedescoGuildford FlamesForwardDavid GoodwinBelfast Giants
Second Team PositionPlayerNationalityTeamGoaltenderMatthew GreenfieldSheffield SteelersDefenceNathanael HalbertCoventry BlazeDefenceBen O'ConnorGuildford FlamesForwardTrevor CoxCardiff DevilsForwardBrett FergusonGuildford FlamesForwardCole SanfordCardiff Devils
2023–2024
First Team PositionPlayerNationalityTeamGoaltenderMatthew GreenfieldSheffield SteelersDefenceMarcus CrawfordCardiff DevilsDefenceKevin TanseySheffield SteelersForwardPatrick WatlingSheffield SteelersForwardCole SanfordCardiff DevilsForwardMitchell BalmasSheffield Steelers
Second Team PositionPlayerNationalityTeamGoaltenderEvan WeningerManchester StormDefenceDrydn DowDundee StarsDefenceColton SaucermanSheffield SteelersForwardGary HadenGlasgow ClanForwardRyan ValentiniDundee StarsForwardSpencer NaasDundee Stars 2024–2025
First Team PositionPlayerNationalityTeamGoaltenderMatthew GreenfieldSheffield SteelersDefenceDrydn DowDundee StarsDefenceJosh RoachBelfast GiantsForwardAlexis D'AoustManchester StormForwardChase GresockCoventry BlazeForwardJosh MacDonaldCardiff Devils
Second Team