William Warelwast (died 1137) was a medieval Norman cleric and Bishop of Exeter in England. Warelwast was a native of Normandy, but little is known about his background before 1087, when he appears as a royal clerk for King William II. Most of his royal service to William was as a diplomatic envoy, as he was heavily involved in the king's dispute with Anselm, the Archbishop of Canterbury, which constituted the English theatre of the Investiture Controversy. He went several times to Rome as an emissary to the papacy on business related to Anselm, one of whose supporters, the medieval chronicler Eadmer, alleged that Warelwast bribed the pope and the papal officials to secure favourable outcomes for King William.
Possibly present at King William's death in a hunting accident, Warelwast served as a diplomat to the king's successor, Henry I. After the resolution of the Investiture Controversy, Warelwast was rewarded with the bishopric of Exeter in Devon, but he continued to serve Henry as a diplomat and royal judge. He began the construction of a new cathedral at Exeter, and he probably divided the diocese into archdeaconries. Warelwast went blind after 1120, and after his death in 1137, was succeeded by his nephew, Robert Warelwast.
Early life Little is known of Warelwast's background or family before 1087. Later in life he was involved in founding Augustinian houses of canons, which – according to historian – implies that he was an Augustinian canon or spent some of his early years in a house of such canons.Blake "Bishop William Warelwast" Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association p. 15 Several medieval chroniclers hostile to Warelwast, including Eadmer, claim that he was illiterate, but his career suggests otherwise, as it involved the extensive use of written documents. He must also have been an accomplished speaker, given the number of times he was used as a diplomat. He was possibly educated at Laon, where later in life he sent his nephew, Robert Warelwast, to school. Another nephew, William, became the bishop's steward.Barlow "Warelwast, William de" Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
Warelwast may have been a clerk for King William I of England, as a confirmation charter from the time of King Stephen (reigned 1135–1154) records that a grant of churches in Exeter was given to Warelwast by "Willelmus, avus meus", or "William, my grandfather/ancestor"; Stephen was a grandson of William I, who reigned 1066–1087. But this charter may be a forgery, or the Willelmus referred to may have been William II rather than William I. The charter itself is insufficient evidence to confidently assert that Warelwast served William I, even though most such grants were made as a reward for royal service. It may have been that Warelwast was awarded land by William I not because he was a royal servant but because he was a relative; certainly, the late-medieval writer William Worcester claimed that Warelwast was related to the king.Blake "Bishop William Warelwast" Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association pp. 15–16
Royal clerk under King William II The first reliable mentions of Warelwast occur early in the reign of King William II, when Warelwast appears as authorizing writs for the king.Barlow William Rufus p. 96 As well as being a royal clerk, Warelwast acted as a judge in a legal case between St Florent Abbey in Saumur and Fécamp Abbey, heard before King William II some time between 1094 and 1099 at Foucarmont.Blake "Bishop William Warelwast" Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association p. 16
Warelwast served as the king's envoy to Pope Urban II in 1095, when the king sought to have the newly appointed Archbishop of Canterbury, Anselm of Canterbury, removed from office.Poole Domesday Book to Magna Carta p. 174 He visited the pope with another royal clerk, Gerard, with orders to recognize Urban as pope in return for Anselm's deposition, at least according to Eadmer, an Anselm partisan. The two clerks travelled very quickly, as they did not leave before 28 February 1095 and were back in England by 13 May 1095.Vaughn Anselm of Bec p. 187 Eadmer claimed that the ambassadors were supposed to acquire a pallium, the symbol of an archbishop's authority, for the king to give to his new choice as archbishop. But although the king may have instructed his envoys to attempt to secure these objects, he was probably willing to negotiate and to settle for less.Barlow William Rufus pp. 342–343 The two clerks returned with a papal legate, Walter of Albano, who accepted the king's recognition of Urban but refused to allow Anselm's deposition.Mason William II Rufus p. 143 The king did nevertheless manage to secure recognition of his royal rights in the church, and a concession that no papal legates or communications would be sent without his approval. It may well be that the king always regarded Anselm's deposition as unlikely.
Warelwast was probably sent as an envoy to Urban in 1096 to bribe the pope into recalling the papal legate Jarento, who had been sent to England to protest the king's conduct towards the church.Barlow William Rufus p. 364 In addition to his ambassadorial duties, Warelwast acted as a royal justice under King William; the records of one case have survived.Barlow William Rufus p. 395
Shortly before Anselm went into exile in 1097, Warelwast searched his baggage,Bartlett England Under the Norman and Angevin Kings p. 405 probably looking for communications to the pope, either from Anselm or other English bishops, rather than for valuables, and in particular for any letters of complaint.Mason William II Rufus pp. 175–178 Warelwast was the king's envoy at Rome when during his exile Anselm petitioned to have the king excommunicated,Poole Domesday Book to Magna Carta p. 177 which according to Eadmer, who was also present, Warelwast succeeded in preventing by bribing the pope and papal officials. The king had sent Warelwast to Urban at Christmas 1098, with his reply to a letter the pope had written ordering the restoration of Anselm's estates.
Royal service for King Henry I
Warelwast may have been with the hunting party on 2 August 1100, in which King William was accidentally killed, as he was one of the witnesses to the letter sent on 5 August 1100 from William II's brother, the new King Henry I, to Anselm, recalling the archbishop.Barlow William Rufus p. 420 King Henry continued to use Warelwast as an ambassador, sending him to Rome in 1101 to bring back Pope Paschal II's reply to a letter written by Henry immediately after his accession. Henry was seeking a reconciliation with the papacy, and confirmed to the pope the rights and obedience which his father had rendered, but he also requested the same rights within the Church as his father had enjoyed, chiefly the lay investiture of bishops and the granting of the symbols of episcopal authority by laymen. Paschal declined to grant Henry those rights.Barlow English Church pp. 297–298Hollister Henry I p. 118
It was Warelwast who told Anselm in 1103 that the king would not permit his return to England. This came after a failed joint mission by Warelwast and Anselm to Paschal, attempting to resolve the dispute between Henry and the archbishop over the king's investiture of bishops, a dispute generally known as the Investiture Controversy. It is quite likely that the king had given instructions that if the mission failed, Warelwast was to inform Anselm that he should only to return to England if he agreed with the king's position in the dispute.Vaughn Anselm of Bec pp. 244–245 In 1106, Warelwast was the king's negotiator in the discussions that led to the settlement of the Investiture Controversy in England.Barlow English Church p. 80 The king ultimately lost little, relinquishing the right to give the actual symbols of episcopal authority to a newly elected bishop in return for continuing to receive homage from the bishops.Huscroft Ruling England pp. 131–132 Early in 1106, Warelwast was sent to Bec Abbey, where Anselm was residing in exile, to inform him of the settlement and deliver to the archbishop the king's invitation to return to England.Hollister Henry I p. 198 In May 1107 Warelwast acted as the king's envoy at Paschal's council at Troyes, where Paschal was attempting to secure support for Bohemond of Antioch's proposed campaign against Byzantium. Warelwast probably relayed to the pope the news that King Henry would make no contribution to Bohemond's efforts.Cantor Church, Kingship, and Lay Investiture p. 264
Henry had reserved the episcopal see of Exeter for Warelwast since the death of Osbern FitzOsbern in 1103, but the controversy over investiture meant that his election and consecration were not possible before a settlement was reached. Instead, the king gave Warelwast the office of Archdeacon of Exeter after Osbern's death. The medieval chronicler William of Malmesbury records that Warelwast had earlier tried to remove Osbern from office, but this story probably originates with Eadmer and is of dubious veracity. While archdeacon, Warelwast is recorded as being present at the transfer of a Devon church to Bath Cathedral.Brett English Church p. 108 He was elected Bishop of Exeter, and was consecrated on 11 August 1107,Fryde, et al. Handbook of British Chronology p. 246 by Anselm at the royal palace of Westminster.Hollister Henry I pp. 209–210 Other bishops consecrated at the same time included William Giffard to Winchester, Roger of Salisbury to Salisbury, Reynelm to Hereford, and Urban to Llandaff. Warelwast's elevation was a reward for his diplomatic efforts in the investiture crisis.Barlow English Church p. 302 The mass consecration signalled the end of the investiture crisis in England.Barlow English Church pp. 78–79
After his consecration, Warelwast continued to serve the king, often appearing on documents or in accounts of the royal court. The bishop served the king as a messenger, once more carrying messages to Anselm in 1108. He also served as a royal judge, hearing a case at Tamworth in 1114 and another at Westbourne the same year. He was with the king in Normandy in 1111, 1113, and 1118, and may have been in Normandy more frequently.Blake "Bishop William Warelwast" Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association p. 23 During Henry's reign Warelwast was a witness to 20 of the king's charters.Newman Anglo-Norman Nobility pp. 183–185
In 1115, Henry sent Warelwast back to Rome to negotiate with Paschal, who was angry that the king was prohibiting papal legates in England, not allowing clerics to appeal to the papal court, and was failing to secure papal sanction for church councils or the translation of bishops. Warelwast was unable to change the pope's mind, but he did manage to prevent sanctions against the king.Hollister Henry I pp. 240–241 Henry also employed Warelwast as a papal envoy during the Canterbury–York disputes over the primacy in the English Church, with visits in 1119, 1120, and possibly also in 1116.
Work as bishop
As a bishop, Warelwast attended the Council of Reims in 1119 along with three other bishops from England,Barlow English Church p. 111 as well as the Council of Rouen in 1118, a provincial synod for Normandy.Spear "Norman Empire" Journal of British Studies p. 3 In his diocese of Exeter he began the construction of a new cathedral in about 1114; it was consecrated in 1133. The existing two towers in the transepts date from that period. He also replaced the secular clergy staffing collegiate churches with regular canons: at Plympton in 1121 with canons from Aldgate in London, and in 1127 at the church in Launceston in Cornwall.Burton Monastic and Religious Orders p. 47 In addition he founded a house of regular canons at Bodmin. Royal charters survive that granted several churches in Cornwall, Devon, and Exeter to Warelwast.Blake "Bishop William Warelwast" Report and Transactions of the Devonshire Association p. 25